In what ways websites/apps track me?

I have read across the privacy report from several "well-established" websites/services like Google/Youtube, Facebook etc. A common theme is "our website may track you using your IP, by using crowd-sourced WiFi hotspots, or through the cellular tower you are connected from". They also sometimes state that they can create a fingerprint of my device to better recognize it.


  • How do they figure out what cell tower I am connected at? Is there any way around such indirect-location-tracking?
  • The device fingerprinting for iOS, includes very vague information like "iPhone 11 Pro Max 64GB" or can the info contain apps installed, system settings etc?


A user's location can, to my understanding, be found indirectly by using the already established crowed-sourced Wi-Fi map. If the nearby Wi-Fi hotspots, or the currently connected one, is known to a certain website, they can infer my location with impressive accuracy.


  • Similar to cell tower tracking, can websites obtain information about nearby (or connected) networks? And again, is there a way to prevent it from happening?


Being a privacy concerned person, I try to protect myself in any way possible and viable.


I try using a respectable VPN service to conceal my identity and presumably encrypt my data on their way. So IP tracking is mitigated, that's the easy one. The rest are the ones I have big problems figuring out...


I have read through the "Location Services & Privacy" page, which is very clear. It states that If I Agree, websites can request for my precise location. GPS location is not shared with the specific party.

While I don't try to say the Apple Privacy Page is lying, it appears that companies have numerous ways to indirectly obtain our location.


  • In what ways iOS makes their attempts more difficult?

iPhone 11 Pro Max, iOS 13

Posted on Jul 11, 2020 12:45 PM

Reply
11 replies

Jul 11, 2020 1:10 PM in response to KayFreeman

There is no such thing as a “very respectable” VPN service, unless you are paying for it. See—>Don't use VPN services. · GitHub


And even if you are paying to use it there is no guarantee that they aren’t either using or selling your information.


Websites cannot access the phone’s location data unless you allow them to. Any site that requests your location will result in a dialog that asks if you agree. That doesn’t prevent the site from using the geographical info associated with your IP address as it would for any device with a web browser.


And your carrier tracks your location all the time; it needs to do this so when someone calls you they know where your phone is. But carriers also sell this information, and provide it to law enforcement when requested. This has nothing to do with iPhones, it’s true for any cell phone.


The information contained in a web reply is very limited; it includes your screen size, IP address, browser type and version, stuff it needs to format the content correctly. It doesn’t include any information from your settings. However, there are services that can use this information to identify who you are, information contained in huge databases that anyone can pay to view.


Apple protects you from tracking via crowd-sourced Wi-Fi networks; it’s a little known feature. When a Wi-Fi network “sees” your phone the phone sends a fake Wi-Fi address to the site, which changes randomly. It only sends the real address if you connect to the site. Which is a good reason to never use public Wi-Fi networks. However, the iPhone does respond to Bluetooth iBeacons if you install any retailer apps that have this enabled. The idea is when you enter a store the merchant can identify you if you have done business with them in the past.


But while we are discussing tracking, here are some notes I have compiled:

  • Your carrier knows the location of your phone all the time, even if you turn off location services, because it can triangulate from the towers that receive your phone’s periodic “I’m here” ping. They are required by law to do this to support E911. They upload this information to databases where your location and whereabouts are known to law enforcement and any business that cares to know where you are.
  • License plate scanners are ubiquitous, in police vehicles and repo trucks. And also along limited access highways, toll roads, bridges and tunnels. And every time your plate is scanned it goes into a location database.
  • Electronic toll tags are obviously used every time you use a toll facility, but transponders are located everywhere along highways for traffic control. Have you see signs that display how long it will take to get to an upcoming milepost? Where do you think they get that information?
  • Do you use public Wi-Fi, your cable provider’s hotspots or the “free” convenient Wi-Fi networks in malls and stores? Did you think that your location wasn’t tracked by those?
  • See those cameras in stores, malls and other public places? Have you heard about facial recognition?
  • Do you have a Transit Pass account?
  • Do you use an urban bicycle rental like New York’s CitiBike? Have you noticed that your usage history shows the location and time you picked up the bike and likewise when you dropped it off?
  • Do you use credit cards in stores? Did you know that the location where you use a card is recorded in a worldwide central database, ostensibly to detect card fraud through what’s called a “velocity check” (AKA as the “superman test”)?
  • Have you heard of iBeacon? It’s a feature that tracks and reports the location of any device that has Bluetooth enabled on a device.
  • What about Find My iPhone, which always knows where your phone is? And its feature added in iOS 12 that uses the Bluetooth signals from other phones to anonymously crowdsource the location of a missing phone?


Apple is about the only business in the world that does NOT track you.



Jul 11, 2020 1:41 PM in response to KayFreeman

ExpressVPN has good reviews, but VPN doesn’t really buy much in the way of privacy, and it can interfere with some things you might want to do, such as update iOS and download some apps.


There actually is a pretty good free privacy app for iPhones and computers; Fyde uses a VPN, so you can’t use it with another VPN, but what it does is strip off most tracking beacons on web requests. Recommended by the NY Times. Some of its features will be in iOS 14 when it comes out. Fyde will block tracking info, and keep a list of what it has blocked for you to view. After just a few days of browsing after I installed it, it blocked over 1,000 3rd party tracking links.

Jul 11, 2020 1:15 PM in response to KayFreeman

several "well-established" websites/services like Google/Youtube, Facebook etc.

Not sure "well-established": equals credible.


Positive Google and Facebook do not equal credible.


On Google you can read the earth is flat and Elvis is alive. Facebook will provide you any theory you wish.


If you don't trust Apple, at least consider other credible sources to vet your concerns.


Reality is, just owning a smart phone has you being tracked. Your carrier knows where you are when connected to their service.


Jonathan gave you good resources as well.


Jul 11, 2020 1:22 PM in response to LACAllen

Yep, official Apple documents.

I can’t enumerate how websites and services track you without writing a research paper.


Considering new web APIs have been released, increasing how a browser can track you and access services on your phone( ones Apple refuses to implement), it gets very complicated.

https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.zdnet.com/google-amp/article/apple-declined-to-implement-16-web-apis-in-safari-due-to-privacy-concerns/

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

In what ways websites/apps track me?

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.