“Card Already In Wallet” from Apple Cash Instant Transfer

Every single time I try an instant transfer it asks me to enter my debit card info. There is no option to select one already in Wallet. So then when I get to the point where I have to enter my card info, I put it in and get the “card already in wallet”. Yet, it won’t let me select any cards already in my wallet. VERY annoying. It’s not just me either, my mom and best friend are experiencing the exact same issue.