Can’t ping my missing AirPods Pro lost in my house!

I lost my AirPods in my house for sure! I’ve looked everywhere. When the one went missing I had just pulled them off the charger and they were fully charged, but for some reason the missing right AirPod pro won’t ping. The left one does. So I mean it’s not out of range and it’s not dead. See the weird white circle around the R? I won’t let me select the right one. I’m super frustrated!

[Image Edited by Moderator to Remove Personal Information]