Yes there are lots of well meaning but ultimately unreliable comments.
Personally, having paid a few grand for an M1 I really don't expect to have to be resorting to tech support for something as basic as wifi connectivity, especially with older standard gear.
I have been looking for a solution to my M1 (and wife & sons iPhones) dropping video for a while during calls, and nothing I have found anywhere has solved the problem. (I mess about a bit in IT so not a complete noob here)
I can buy a product for a quarter of the price and it works perfectly.................... that really is a kick in the teeth.
From testing I am pretty certain it is related to my routers that it does not like - if I connect to say my Android mobile via hotspot it seems OK. My wifes iPhones are really not happy either, particularly with Facetime, but equally Jitsi, Whatsapp etc. She has to turn off wifi to make a call.
I have a Gigabit fibre connection through the ISP modem with PPPoE on a Mikrotik router. Data speed tests on the 5Ghz wifi run around 2-300 Mps which is fine for me. I'm after reliability on this, not outright speed here.
I have a bunch of older Netgear PoE APs running 2.4Ghz 'g' fixed 20Mhz and 5Ghz 'an' running 20/40Mhz dynamic as recommended (along with all the other recommended settings I can find eg WMM etc) They all have the same SSID so you can roam easily. It isn't like they are new and flakey. All my non cheaper Apple kit works fine with them with no issues.
Under normal surfing/browsing it seems to be fine with plenty of speed, but video calls are a fail - I can see it sit at around 4Mbs and it then literally just drops, and then after a bit of a pause it picks up again. My even *older* 2.4Ghz 'g' only APs were actually *more* reliable for video (but slow)!! Same results with browsers or apps. I have tested til my eyes bled and I am fed up with reconfiguring things 99 times.
Under Wifi diagnostics RSSI and NSR seem fine. I've removed all other AP settings, renamed an AP SSID to simulate a different network for good measure so it doesn't try and channel hop, and it still does pauses/drops. I can see that sometimes it seems the drops are associated with a drop in speed, but other times it can show a steady 300Mbs and pause/hang the call. The application just sits there and waits for a reconnection. I can only presume that it is the internal hardware or software having a hissy fit and trying to renegotiate something it doesn't need too.
Interestingly, while on a video call on the M1 even pinging my local server or gateway through a terminal times out. That really makes zero sense. Seems like the network is overloaded, even when it is using less than 1Mbs. WHAT???????
Clearly there is an issue with certain access points that no one has got to the bottom of. I have learned a lot about the diagnostic capabilities of a Macbook, some of which is pretty arcane and obscure, and can see certain things in the logs, but depressingly no information on them anywhere. But ultimately if it says it supports some or other protocol, be it b/g/n it has to work.
All in all a frustrating experience for the money, and I won't be doing it again in a hurry. I'll be sticking to my linux based kit in future.
Now off to blow my brains out for a load of new (non Apple) access points because it is easier than fighting this thing. Joy.
"Disappointed"