changejobs wrote:
bob,
thank you for your detailed post. this seems quite interesting. however I realize my desktop is about 6 years old so id worry about the drive. i have a new 2gb external drive and i'd actually like to use it to back up both my desktop and my 1 year old laptop with any future backups. although i plugged it into my router, i cant figure out how to see the drive and start the process. any thoughts appreciated
First you can specify the external disk as the destination for the network Time Machine backups.
Second, just like the Time Capsule, you can backup multiple Macs to the 2TB external drive.
As to your 6 year old boot disk, you could buy a USB3 SSD, transfer your macOS to SSD, and boot from that. It will actually make your desktop Mac faster, assuming it is running off of a rotating disk.
If you want an NAS, then I have been using Synology.
I have 2 of Synology NAS boxes (one backs up the other). However, I do not use Time Machine, rather I use Carbon Copy Cloner to do my backups. It is a bit of a Rube Goldberg setup, where I have an old Mac running Carbon Copy Cloner. It mounts an SMB Share from the Synology. On the SMB share is a macOS Disk Utility image file, which CCC also mounts. I then use CCC's ability to pull a backup from my Mac over the network (local home network in this case, but it could be across the Internet, if the remote Mac has a dynamic DNS name that can be addressed, and appropriate ssh ports have been opened in the remote Mac's home router).
I backup 4 Mac laptops in my home, and before my mother passed away, I backed up her iMac from 300 miles away using this Rube Goldberg approach.
As you may guess I have a lot of storage on my Synology boxes. About 20TB
NOTE: If you get a NAS I would suggest using NAS rated drives. They are more expensive than your typical consumer drive, but in a NAS box, they will generally last longer.