Facetime Shareplay

Thanks for providing that information, AxlBoy69. It's appreciated.

Watch movies and TV shows together in FaceTime on your iPhone or iPad - Apple Support -- The second footnote at the bottom of this article states, "Some content might not be supported if SharePlay users are in different countries or regions." Are both of you in the same country/region?

Get Support -- If you are, we recommend contacting Apple Support to look into this further. Choose Apps & Features > FaceTime not working as expected to reach them.

Thanks for using Apple Support Communities!

Since everything seems to have been set up correctly, AxlBoy69, please contact Apple Support for a closer look. You use the link and path we provided previously.

All the best.

Hey AxlBoy69,

It appears that you're having problems using SharePlay between your iPhone and a friend's, and we're glad to provide assistance.

Use SharePlay to watch and listen together in FaceTime on iPhone - Apple Support -- Please review this page of the iPhone User Guide. 

If everything is as it's supposed to be, please reply to this post with more detail about the issue.

All the best.