Final Cut Pro X make my images and video in lower quality

Hello, I am new here and I am desperate about my problem with FCPX I am doing a video with movies and pictures, all my movies and pictures in the Final Cut X Library are in the same best quality as I have taken and exported from Photos, and when I select them from the library and watch them on the video window in FCPX they look the same with the best quality as I imported, the problem arrives when I watch them from the timeline and once exported the video, they are in lower quality, a bit blur and you can notice the difference of quality very well.


I normally export my files from photos to a folder and then I drag them in the timeline, I do not think it is the source of the problem because all the files are in the best quality once I watch them from the Final Cut Pro X library. 


The problem is not the BETTER QUALITY INSTED OF THE BETTER PERFORMANCE OR OPTIMISED/ORIGINAL instead of proxy, as I read in all the blogs, because I have tried them all and the quality is even worse.

My original pictures are taken in 6016x4016 and the videos are pretty all in 4k ( iPhone and Nikon compact camera and Nikon D750) quality, I made the video in Final Cut Pro in 1080p HD 1920x1080, rendering standard as FCP choice: AppleProRes422, and I use MEDIA PLAYBACK : OPTIMISED/ORIGINAL, it is not normal that with these quality options all my pictures loose quality and videos too, so I tried also to change the quality of the FCPX video in 4k and the problem still there, when I see the picture or the video in the timeline with the preview and also once exported the images are in lower quality and a bit blur, and when I watch the same pictures and video trough my FCPX library are in perfect quality with the original quality.


Could someone help me please? because I do not really know what to do and I am sure that there is a problem.


thank you very much


Paolo


MacBook Pro 15″, macOS 12.1

Posted on Jan 16, 2022 7:55 AM

Reply

Similar questions

21 replies

Jan 18, 2022 7:56 AM in response to paolopescia

As I said before, it should work fine. A few visual examples might help us better understand what is going wrong, and maybe progress towards a solution.


If you are using some third party effects, that is something that is worth look at - maybe there are some that need to be updated.


Also, in case there is some problem with other third party software, which could affect the way FCP works: Please run Etrecheck and post its full report here. Use the "additional text" button and paste the report into the text box.

Jan 18, 2022 8:29 AM in response to paolopescia

You can get Etrecheck from its website, but in the present case I think that you probably should edit in 4K.

Make a test: duplicate one 1080 project, open the copy in the timeline, then press Command-J to open the Project Inspector; click Modify, and change the frame size to 4K. Export as H264, and view that in your large screen TV. How do they compare?


It is one thing to make a project for youtube, where most viewers will never see the greatest possible quality. But if you are targetting 4K TV, and your material is 4K or larger, then by all means edit in 4K.




Jan 18, 2022 8:03 PM in response to paolopescia

The suggestion Luis provides in using a 4K Timeline is my first option in your case.


Regards Exports:


Have you considered using the Apple App called Compressor?

It works in concert with FCPro to a large degree when controlling your Exports.

FCPro has "canned" options that cannot be altered.

Compressor allows fine tuning of the file to gain the best quality and the lowest file size.


This juggling of the file is an art that needs to be understood to get the best results.

Read the manual before proceeding.


Al

Jan 18, 2022 8:10 AM in response to paolopescia

It's probably more noticeable in this image than most because it so highly complex and difficult to encode, very small objects, probably moving in the wind, about the hardest thing for video to compress well. The only thing that would make it more difficult would be if it was red.


H.264 is a heavily compressed codec and will reduce the quality of the image further. Try a short section to see what it looks like.

Jan 18, 2022 8:45 AM in response to paolopescia

I think that the problem is in the opposite direction. You are upscaling the 1080 content to view on a large 4K monitor.

When you upscale, the system has to either quadruple every pixel or make up pixels that weren't there. Now in many cases, depending on the screen, and the viewing distance, the result can be quite acceptable.

It is clear that this is not the case for you - hence my suggestion that you stick with 4K.


Video always takes up a lot of space, but in most cases the bulk of it is made of render files and optimized files. You can throw these away. In fact, you should not need to create any optimized media, or proxy media; and if you turn off "background render" you will also create a lot less render files.


A 4K H264 file is typically much smaller than a 1080 ProRes file. And if you can go with HEVC, you can have even smaller files (that is, if your TV supports HEVC; many don't, at least for now).

Jan 18, 2022 11:56 AM in response to paolopescia

Photoshop is for still images. You absolutely cannot compare stills and video. Most cameras shoot using codecs that capture groups of pictures; only the first frame in the GOP is a complete frame, the subsequent 14 frames usually are dependent on calculations of changes between the frames done in real time as the shots are recorded. Your images are extremely difficult to encode and will show more loss when they are compressed in editing. I don’t think your expectations of what can be achieved at lower resolutions is realistic, especially with heavily compressed codecs that cameras often use.

Jan 18, 2022 7:14 AM in response to Alchroma

Hello, Thank you very much, I still have the same problem of the exported file in the timeline preview, I tried to double my project and make it in 4k at maximum resolution and the quality is much better, but the file is 850GB!!!

my videos are in 4k 60fps and 30fps taken with iPhone and a little Nikon camera, I know that shrinking 4K video down to 1080. I'd not think that was too much, but shrinking can degrade an image. Not as quickly as enlarging, but it can. I doubt that is what's happening, and my timeline is at 24fps.


I still do not understand because I have always made videos with my pictures at 1080p without loosing quality but not this time...

I heard that there is a setting that make all your file quality as the first video you put in the timeline, where can I find it please?


Why do I have to export my video with 850GB (2.5h of video/pictures) to not loose quality? because if the problem is that my pictures loose quality because they where taken at 6016x4016 with my Nikon and they are decrease down to a 1080p HD 1920x1080 video, I can not believe that they loose the quality, it would be the contrary that does!



Thank you very much



Jan 18, 2022 8:05 AM in response to Tom Wolsky

I did not imagine that could loose so much quality like the picture I attached in the previous message, so I need to make all my videos in 4k with my 6016x4016 pictures? but they are too heavy, there must be a solution to make a reasonable videos not too heavy with the same quality, I have never noticed such a difference of quality in my reduced 1920x1080 pictures, I could watch them in a big screen and looked the same as the originals ones!


If I export at H264 do I loose quality of the video?


Thank you

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

Final Cut Pro X make my images and video in lower quality

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.