External drive not mounting after upgrading from Lion to El Capitan
I recently upgraded my early 2011 MBP from Lion to El Capitan (to then proceed to High Sierra). I set up a Seagate external drive as my Time Machine drive and the backup went smoothly under Lion. But now in El Capitan (10.11.16) the external drive won't mount. I can see it's connected as a USB device through System Information but it won't actually mount. I've tried restarting, powering off and back on, both with the drive connected and connecting it after logging in. The issue is the same under SafeBoot. Already did SMC reset and PRAM reset. Nothing helps. I don't have another computer to check the drive but it was perfectly fine right before.
Any ideas on what else I can try next? I need to backup before I can proceed with upgrading to High Sierra.
MacBook Pro 13″, OS X 10.11