Siri Using Apple Music Instead of Spotify

I can tell Siri to play music on Spotify and it works perfectly, but whenever I say "Add song to queue" she says "you need to update your apple music subscription for me to do that". I have tried adding "on Spotify" to the end of the statement but that doesn't work. I have "Show Apple Music" turned off in music settings and I have every single Siri option turned on in the Spotify settings.

How do I fix this so I can add songs on queue? It's very frustrating on my two hour long drives every day.