external hard drives vs SSD

I have 2 questions, first I need to know which is better for my new MacBook Air, a External hard direct or an SSD. I am only really moving stuff from one Mac to the next.

My next questions is I need to move a great amount of music files from an old PC to either my Mac or an external device of some kind. Which is the best way to go about this?

MacBook Air, macOS 12.5

Posted on Sep 11, 2022 8:46 AM

Reply
Question marked as Top-ranking reply

Posted on Sep 11, 2022 9:00 AM

A HDD is cheaper. You don't really need an SSD for this specific task.


You can re-use the drive for a backup disk on the new Mac once you are done moving things, so buy one with at least twice the storage size of your new MacBook Air.

If you want to do that, an SSD is more durable. If you accidentally drop a HDD while it is running, even from a very low height, it will crash the drive.

If it was a desktop Mac, I would purchase a HDD for the cost benefit. But, for a mobile device, I would get an SSD for the durability.


Regardless, the format of the drive won't matter if moving from PC to Mac. Almost all drives come formatted NTFS (Windows). Your PC can write to it, and your Mac can Read from it.

Once you're done moving things and want to use it with your Mac, you'll need to format the drive for use on your Mac. If only using on your Mac, use APFS with GUID Partition Map. If you want to be able to use with Windows PCs and your Mac, use ExFAT.

Similar questions

3 replies
Question marked as Top-ranking reply

Sep 11, 2022 9:00 AM in response to LynnHammond

A HDD is cheaper. You don't really need an SSD for this specific task.


You can re-use the drive for a backup disk on the new Mac once you are done moving things, so buy one with at least twice the storage size of your new MacBook Air.

If you want to do that, an SSD is more durable. If you accidentally drop a HDD while it is running, even from a very low height, it will crash the drive.

If it was a desktop Mac, I would purchase a HDD for the cost benefit. But, for a mobile device, I would get an SSD for the durability.


Regardless, the format of the drive won't matter if moving from PC to Mac. Almost all drives come formatted NTFS (Windows). Your PC can write to it, and your Mac can Read from it.

Once you're done moving things and want to use it with your Mac, you'll need to format the drive for use on your Mac. If only using on your Mac, use APFS with GUID Partition Map. If you want to be able to use with Windows PCs and your Mac, use ExFAT.

Sep 11, 2022 8:51 AM in response to LynnHammond

  1. An external SSD is faster and more reliable than an old rotating HD
  2. Attach the external device to the old computer, copy off the data, attach the external device to the new computer and use the data. Or, if you want the data on your new computer rather than on the external drive, after attaching the external drive with the datat to your new compuuter just copy/move the data to the computer's drive.

Sep 11, 2022 9:30 AM in response to LynnHammond

LynnHammond wrote:

My next questions is I need to move a great amount of music files from an old PC to either my Mac or an external device of some kind. Which is the best way to go about this?

If both PC and Mac are on your home network, then you can use some form of network sharing between the 2 devices. Either share your PC disk via Windows sharing and connect that share to your Mac, or share from the Mac and connect your PC to that share. Either way you can then drag and drop files between the 2 computers.

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

external hard drives vs SSD

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.