Hi Rob_H1,
I had a closer look at one of the log files (iCloudPrefs.xxxx.log in AppData\Local\Packages\AppleInc.iCloud_nzyj5cx40ttqa\LocalCache\Local\Logs). Comparing the logs for the failing and successful accounts, I see the differences I copied below. Somehow the authentication goes wrong for the failing account, while I am using exactly the same credentials in both cases. (BTW, I replaced my AppleID by xxx.yyy.zz)
Failed login:
[47888 @ Tues Nov 15 2022 11:51:20.600] 43324 info Authenticator::AuthKitCallback AuthKit returned control
[47888 @ Tues Nov 15 2022 11:51:20.602] 43324 info UIThreadMarshaler::Run Posting func: >>>> OnAuthKitComplete
[47888 @ Tues Nov 15 2022 11:51:20.602] 47892 info App::DispatchAction Dispatching action 'UpdateUIState'
[47888 @ Tues Nov 15 2022 11:51:20.604] 47892 debug App::DispatchAction::action_visitor::operator () UI state: working: false, visible: false
[47888 @ Tues Nov 15 2022 11:51:20.606] 47892 info UIThreadMarshaler::Run Posting func: >>>> OnStateChange (from Show)
[47888 @ Tues Nov 15 2022 11:51:20.611] 47892 debug Authenticator::OnAuthKitComplete AuthKit said to quit
[47888 @ Tues Nov 15 2022 11:51:20.612] 47892 info UIThreadMarshaler::Run Posting func: >>>> Complete(Quit)
[47888 @ Tues Nov 15 2022 11:51:20.613] 47892 info PreferencesUI::PreferencesWnd::SetState UI visible: false, signed in: false, web app loaded: true
[47888 @ Tues
Successful login:
[7256 @ Tues Nov 15 2022 11:56:49.340] 19240 info Authenticator::AuthKitCallback AuthKit returned control
[7256 @ Tues Nov 15 2022 11:56:49.341] 19240 info UIThreadMarshaler::Run Posting func: >>>> OnAuthKitComplete
[7256 @ Tues Nov 15 2022 11:56:49.342] 47440 info Authenticator::OnAuthKitComplete AuthKit transaction complete
[7256 @ Tues Nov 15 2022 11:56:49.344] 47440 debug Authenticator::AuthenticateWithICloud Queueing iCloud authentication
[7256 @ Tues Nov 15 2022 11:56:49.345] 46224 debug Authenticator::AuthenticateWithICloud::<lambda_9e5bb2233cef2ea81fed3c9724d6db53>::operator () Authenticating with iCloud...
[7256 @ Tues Nov 15 2022 11:56:49.346] 46224 info App::SignIn Signing in...
[7256 @ Tues Nov 15 2022 11:56:49.347] 46224 info App::RefreshNetworkAvailability Refreshing network availability
[7256 @ Tues Nov 15 2022 11:56:49.349] 46224 info App::DispatchAction Dispatching action 'NetworkStatusChange'
[7256 @ Tues Nov 15 2022 11:56:49.350] 46224 info UIThreadMarshaler::Run Posting func: >>>> OnStateChange (from Show)
[7256 @ Tues Nov 15 2022 11:56:49.351] 46224 info App::DispatchAction Dispatching action 'UpdateUIState'
[7256 @ Tues Nov 15 2022 11:56:49.352] 46224 debug App::DispatchAction::action_visitor::operator () UI state: working: true, visible: true
[7256 @ Tues Nov 15 2022 11:56:49.353] 46224 info UIThreadMarshaler::Run Posting func: >>>> OnStateChange (from Show)
[7256 @ Tues Nov 15 2022 11:56:49.353] 47440 info PreferencesUI::PreferencesWnd::SetState UI visible: true, signed in: false, web app loaded: true
[7256 @ Tues Nov 15 2022 11:56:49.355] 47440 info UIThreadMarshaler::Run Posting func: >>>> Hide Window
[7256 @ Tues Nov 15 2022 11:56:49.354] 46224 info App::RefreshICloudAccount Refreshing iCloud account state
[7256 @ Tues Nov 15 2022 11:56:49.357] 46224 info iCloudAccount::SignIn Refreshing account xxx@yyy.zz...
[7256 @ Tues Nov 15 2022 11:56:49.356] 47440 info PreferencesUI::PreferencesWnd::SetState UI visible: true, signed in: false, web app loaded: true
[7256 @ Tues Nov 15 2022 11:56:49.373] 47440 info UIThreadMarshaler::Run Posting func: >>>> Hide Window
[7256 @ Tues Nov 15 2022 11:56:50.414] 46224 info iCloudAccount::SignIn Account refresh successful.
[7256 @ Tues Nov 15 2022 11:56:50.429] 46224 info iCloudAccount::WriteAccountToRegistry Successfully wrote accountid xxx@yyy.zz to registry.
[7256 @ Tues Nov 15 2022 11:56:50.431] 46224 info iCloudAccount::WriteAccountToRegistry Successfully wrote account type 1 to registry.