USB storage without external power

I’m well aware that you can’t use most storage with a lightning equipped iPad without using additional power. I’ve used a variety of storage devices including HDD with my iPad Pro 10.5 using the Apple adapter.

I use SD cards quite happily without additional power and I have also used USB sticks in the same way but most modern USB sticks seem to need more power than the iPad can supply.

My question therefore is why do SD cards need less power and do any of you know of any low power USB sticks that work? I’m guessing they may need to be USB 2.0. As I say, I have had USB sticks that did used to work. TIA. I should also add that storage “sticks” made Sandisk and Lexar work without additional power or an adapter but I don’t like their proprietary file structure.

Is the Apple adapter itself at fault or is it just indifference by USB stick manufacturers?

iPad Pro 10.5-inch, Wi-Fi

Posted on Jan 5, 2023 5:21 AM

Reply
Question marked as Top-ranking reply

Posted on Jan 5, 2023 6:22 AM

SD Cards are inherently designed to be low power devices. USB devices are not necessarily designed with ultra-low power requirements in mind.


All USB devices have device attributes - that are interrogated by the host controller during the initial device-connection handshake. Among the attributes are the USB device type/class (e.g., printer, hub, smart card, audio, mass storage) and power requirements (in mA). This information ensures that the appropriate device-driver is loaded - and that the host interface can provide adequate power.


Unless independently powered, USB devices are powered by the USB bus. Some types of storage device require more power than a single (or multiple) USB port can provide - this being particularly problematic for small portable electronic devices that are themselves battery powered. As storage devices get larger, with faster interfaces, power requirements increase - and for this reason alone, many modern USB flash drives require more power than their older cousins.


Modern USB storage devices often declare a minimum power requirement of 500mA - this being greater than the Lightning port of an iPad or iPhone are designed to source. When used with an external power source (as supported by Apple’s Lightning to USB3 Camera Adapter), the iPad’s limited ability to source high power via its Lightning port is mitigated.


While you may be able to find USB flash storage devices that have lower power needs, you’ll likely encounter a substantial trade-off in both storage capacity and transfer speed - i.e., they will have low capacity and be very slow to transfer data.

2 replies
Question marked as Top-ranking reply

Jan 5, 2023 6:22 AM in response to Pavaise

SD Cards are inherently designed to be low power devices. USB devices are not necessarily designed with ultra-low power requirements in mind.


All USB devices have device attributes - that are interrogated by the host controller during the initial device-connection handshake. Among the attributes are the USB device type/class (e.g., printer, hub, smart card, audio, mass storage) and power requirements (in mA). This information ensures that the appropriate device-driver is loaded - and that the host interface can provide adequate power.


Unless independently powered, USB devices are powered by the USB bus. Some types of storage device require more power than a single (or multiple) USB port can provide - this being particularly problematic for small portable electronic devices that are themselves battery powered. As storage devices get larger, with faster interfaces, power requirements increase - and for this reason alone, many modern USB flash drives require more power than their older cousins.


Modern USB storage devices often declare a minimum power requirement of 500mA - this being greater than the Lightning port of an iPad or iPhone are designed to source. When used with an external power source (as supported by Apple’s Lightning to USB3 Camera Adapter), the iPad’s limited ability to source high power via its Lightning port is mitigated.


While you may be able to find USB flash storage devices that have lower power needs, you’ll likely encounter a substantial trade-off in both storage capacity and transfer speed - i.e., they will have low capacity and be very slow to transfer data.

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

USB storage without external power

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.