What is the best cost effective option for an external drive for time machine backs for a M2 Macbook Pro with a 8TB hard drive?

what is the best cost effective and reliable options for external drive for a M2 Macbook Pro with 8TB hard drive?

When i upgraded to the new M2 MacBook Pro I went wit the 8TB hard drive that can hold my entire current Lightroom photo library from the last 18 years and still have another 3 TB of room.

Not sure what is a good reliable external drive setup to use as a time machine. My past time machine consisted of two G Armor shock proof 5TB drives (for redundancy), and had the rest of my Lightroom library on separate eternal drives. However, the 5TB drives were for my old McBook Pro that only had 2TB of memory.


Not sure what to use now for the new MacBook Pro. Note that I'm not interested in doing icloud time machine backups.

MacBook Pro (M2, 2022)

Posted on Aug 6, 2023 10:02 AM

Reply
Question marked as Top-ranking reply

Posted on Aug 6, 2023 10:33 AM

Welcome!


First, I confess to putting the "cost-effective option" part in abeyance when I asked myself, "What are my photos and files worth?" I'd suffered with cheap external drives, both mine and those on friends' computers that I support, and finally said "Enough!"


For TM, an SSD is overkill. A USB3 drive enclosure with a quality SATA 6, 7200-rpm mech drive inside is more than fast enough once the initial backup is finished.


For best reliability, I use only self-powered enclosures (they have an independent power supply) that hold desktop-class 3.5-inch mechanical drives. For drives inside, I avoid the entry-level stuff that most drive makers offer to placate the mass merchants. All my TM drives have WD "Black" series drives which have been a good blend of reliability and cost. I use these empty enclosures:


https://eshop.macsales.com/item/OWC/ME3NH7T00/


It takes minutes to install a bare drive in those enclosures.


As for size, the traditional recommendation has been 2-3X the size of the internal drive it backs up. I use 2X. My iMac has a 1TB factory SSD about 60% full and has been backing up to the same drive since 1 April 2019 when I installed new new 2TB external drive. After over four years, it still has its first backup and is under 80% full. That works for me. Your mileage may vary.

Similar questions

5 replies
Question marked as Top-ranking reply

Aug 6, 2023 10:33 AM in response to kssheikh

Welcome!


First, I confess to putting the "cost-effective option" part in abeyance when I asked myself, "What are my photos and files worth?" I'd suffered with cheap external drives, both mine and those on friends' computers that I support, and finally said "Enough!"


For TM, an SSD is overkill. A USB3 drive enclosure with a quality SATA 6, 7200-rpm mech drive inside is more than fast enough once the initial backup is finished.


For best reliability, I use only self-powered enclosures (they have an independent power supply) that hold desktop-class 3.5-inch mechanical drives. For drives inside, I avoid the entry-level stuff that most drive makers offer to placate the mass merchants. All my TM drives have WD "Black" series drives which have been a good blend of reliability and cost. I use these empty enclosures:


https://eshop.macsales.com/item/OWC/ME3NH7T00/


It takes minutes to install a bare drive in those enclosures.


As for size, the traditional recommendation has been 2-3X the size of the internal drive it backs up. I use 2X. My iMac has a 1TB factory SSD about 60% full and has been backing up to the same drive since 1 April 2019 when I installed new new 2TB external drive. After over four years, it still has its first backup and is under 80% full. That works for me. Your mileage may vary.

Aug 6, 2023 12:39 PM in response to kssheikh

The "best" choice is up to you, but two brand name HDDs is my recommendation for adequate data security of that much data.


But with the size drive you have, you're going to be into a little money here. How much is your data worth to you?


Just don't fall into the "Eggs in one basket" trap. With a drive that size, the tendency is to load it up. Just recently on this very community a poster was woefully regretting that decision coupled with no backups.


I use worst case analysis when it comes to backups: Plan for the worst; hope for the best.

Aug 6, 2023 1:11 PM in response to ku4hx

Is getting two 16tb WD red pro NAS drives and orico enclosure for each a good option?


with NAs hard drives like the WD red pro drives, can you just have them on when plugging into the MacBook Pro monthly, or when I import or make a lot of updates in LR? I had read somewhere that these drives are not deaigned to be turned on and off, and need to be continuously spinning. Is that true?


im trying to get away with having 4 or 2tb to 5tb portable WD/g-drives sitting in my drawers, and then trying to figure out what is in each drive.

Aug 6, 2023 4:37 PM in response to kssheikh

Modern drives larger than about 4GB are often assumed to be always running. Because of this, on some models, the electronic brake has been removed.


That sounds fine, until you want to choose Restart off the  menu. Often the drives do not spin down fast enough, and so when the Mac start up again, they show status: not ready, and are not mounted.


The solution is DON'T Restart. Instead, choose Shutdown, count to ten, then start up again.

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

What is the best cost effective option for an external drive for time machine backs for a M2 Macbook Pro with a 8TB hard drive?

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.