Macbook Pro Early 2015 (Intel) stuck at progress bar during Internet recovery and booting from USB Media

I have an Intel-based Macbook Pro. It was up-to-date, running Monterey. Couple days ago, the screen didn't show up after lifting up the lid. I shut it down using the power button. When I open it again, the progress bar was stuck around 3-5%. I tried shutting it down and opening it back using the power button. There was no change. I left it open all night long to see if it is not stuck but really doing something. The progress bar was at exactly the same location in the morning. The fan works loudly during progress bar.


Below are several solution I tried and none of them worked.


1-CMD+R to open recovery menu -> It again stuck at the progress bar.

2-Option+CMD+R and Shift+Option+CMD+R -> First, it was giving me some errors but then I was able to connect to wifi. It counted down 3-4 mins. I guess it was downloading something. After it is done, it stuck again at the progress bar.

3-(kind of work around) Holding down Option -> It showed me boot options successfully. I connected to internet on this screen and tried Option+CMD+R and Shift+Option+CMD+R. The result was the same. Stuck at progress bar.

4-I created a bootable USB for Monterey. It showed up in boot menu. I clicked on it. It again stuck at progress bar. I checked it on M1 Macbook. I was able to boot from that drive.

5-I created another bootable USB using another USB stick. The result was the same.

6-I opened the Macbook (physically) and took the SSD (512G Samsung) out. Tried to boot from the USB. I didn't get anything on the screen.

7-I put it back and tried again. No change. Stuck at progress bar.


Bonus-I created a bootable Ubuntu. I was able to boot from that Ubuntu USB and successfully accessed my files on Machintosh HD under APFS. The disk was not encrypted.


What could be the problem? What else can I try?Could it be the main board? Could it be the battery? I am familiar with linux and windows, installing them, booting them from USBs but I don't know how Apple tie things together so one error could lead to another one.


Thanks for your help!

Posted on Oct 6, 2023 1:13 PM

Reply
Question marked as Top-ranking reply

Posted on Oct 7, 2023 12:29 PM

symkrk wrote:

6-I opened the Macbook (physically) and took the SSD (512G Samsung) out. Tried to boot from the USB. I didn't get anything on the screen.

Either your USB boot drive is bad (the OS or the USB drive/stick), or you have a hardware issue with the laptop. Did you also remove the SSD adapter? Macs can be very picky about the drives used for booting, both internal & external. What happens if you try booting into Internet Recovery Mode using Command + Option + R with the internal SSD & adapter removed so we can eliminate any issue with the USB stick or USB installer?


Bonus-I created a bootable Ubuntu. I was able to boot from that Ubuntu USB and successfully accessed my files on Machintosh HD under APFS. The disk was not encrypted.

With the Retina model Apple laptops, Linux may be able to function when macOS cannot since Linux may be accessing the hardware in a slightly different manner. I know this is definitely true for the Keyboard & Trackpad on the 2015 model.


Could it be the main board?

Possibly. Try running the Apple Diagnostics to see if any hardware issues are detected. Most likely the diagnostics will report an issue with the third party SSD which can be ignored. If you have the original Apple SSD, then try it with the diagnostics.


Could it be the battery?

Unlikely.

Similar questions

3 replies
Question marked as Top-ranking reply

Oct 7, 2023 12:29 PM in response to symkrk

symkrk wrote:

6-I opened the Macbook (physically) and took the SSD (512G Samsung) out. Tried to boot from the USB. I didn't get anything on the screen.

Either your USB boot drive is bad (the OS or the USB drive/stick), or you have a hardware issue with the laptop. Did you also remove the SSD adapter? Macs can be very picky about the drives used for booting, both internal & external. What happens if you try booting into Internet Recovery Mode using Command + Option + R with the internal SSD & adapter removed so we can eliminate any issue with the USB stick or USB installer?


Bonus-I created a bootable Ubuntu. I was able to boot from that Ubuntu USB and successfully accessed my files on Machintosh HD under APFS. The disk was not encrypted.

With the Retina model Apple laptops, Linux may be able to function when macOS cannot since Linux may be accessing the hardware in a slightly different manner. I know this is definitely true for the Keyboard & Trackpad on the 2015 model.


Could it be the main board?

Possibly. Try running the Apple Diagnostics to see if any hardware issues are detected. Most likely the diagnostics will report an issue with the third party SSD which can be ignored. If you have the original Apple SSD, then try it with the diagnostics.


Could it be the battery?

Unlikely.

Oct 8, 2023 11:34 AM in response to symkrk

Since you can boot the Apple Diagnostics, but not a macOS installer (USB or online)....that tells me you must have some sort of hardware issue which is only affecting macOS. The online diagnostics leverages same framework which is used to boot into the online macOS installer....the only difference is the diagnostic does not load macOS & is much more minimal. It is also interesting you cannot boot a macOS USB installer on this Mac, but the installer works for another Mac. Plus the issue just occurred suddenly according to your initial post.


Unfortunately I don't know what the hardware issue could be. Have you tried booting into Safe Mode with the SSD? Safe Mode may even disable some macOS drivers or can utilize a different more basic driver as in the case of a GPU driver.



symkrk wrote:

If I try to wipe the SSD and install Ubuntu, do you think I can install mac any time later?

Usually I would say yes, but Apple seems to be taking the online recovery mode servers offline...at least that is what I'm gathering from Apple's deafening silence to people being unable to utilize recovery mode for some older Macs & installers since people have been reporting issues for over a month now.


If you have a bootable macOS USB installer, or you have access to another compatible Mac in order to create a bootable macOS USB installer, then yes it should be possible.


This all assumes you have no hardware issues which prevents the macOS installer or even macOS from working.


Would a successfull boot from USB install all the necessary partitions on the disk?

macOS installer....no, the user must use Disk Utility to properly erase the SSD.


Ubuntu....I don't recall its default option or behavior since I haven't used Ubuntu in years as I've moved on to another Linux distribution. IIRC, Ubuntu has an option to use the entire drive or to utilize an empty unpartitioned area of a disk (since macOS & Disk Utility doesn't leave any unpartitioned space on the drive you would use the Linux installer to delete the particular partition so you can utilize its space by Linux).


I would recommend practicing by installing Ubuntu to an external drive so you can see first hand how the Ubuntu installer works and the options it offers for preparing the drive. Making a mistake on an external drive won't hurt anything since you can just start over again as long as you don't touch the internal drive. If the Ubuntu installer prompts you for where to install the bootloader, just make sure to select the external drive (it won't really hurt anything if the internal drive is selected, but it allows the external drive to be bootable on its own if moved to another computer (it only installs a folder with a few files onto the hidden ESP/EFI partition so not a big deal).


I wanna use my machine as a computer, not necessarily as a mac, instead of throwing it into the bin.

Linux would definitely allow you to do this.


Just remember you need to learn a bit about Linux and how it works if you want to have a good experience with it. You don't need to learn a lot, just some basics about how it identifies drives & partitions, basic partitioning information since you are already asking questions about installation. Understanding some basics about the distribution's package management behavior (aka software updates, software installation & removal) is also a good idea since this is where many people tend to make mistakes.


I also recommend learning the very basics of using the command line since you will likely need to use it at some point since most online help will have you issuing commands....it is the quickest & easiest way to access information & features since the graphical interface may not provide access (and there are several different GUI interfaces). Never blindly use commands found online since they may be tailored for a very specific case or system, plus many times there can be multiple ways to achieve a task (some are terrible but can work, other ways are better, and some ways may be best or more elegant.... and less risky). Best to examine multiple articles & forum posts before utilizing commands found online & to use your own brain to attempt to understand what those commands do.


You cannot really learn much about Linux until you actually install it and try it....learning really comes just by doing a bit of research when you encounter an issue or a question. If you have the very basics listed, then it makes everything else so much easier if a problem is encountered since you can focus on the issue and not on understanding the behavior of the OS or its tools & utilities. With Ubuntu & Linux Mint, it is possible to use the OS without more than a basic understanding.


Oct 8, 2023 7:39 AM in response to HWTech

I forget to mention that I previously run diagnostics, holding down D during start up. It didn't find anything wrong. There was a success code something like ADP000. But SDD was inside.


I did run diagnostics again after removing SSD. Everything is original btw. Samsung SSD is the original SSD of the macbook. There is no adapter. Just the socket and the SSD. Pretty much the same with the picture I attached. The result was VDH002 saying that there may be an issue with a storage device. Obviously, it was not there.


I tried opening mac again without SSD. This time I was able to get the boot menu on the screen, pressing down Option. Internet recovery showed up visually. That was interesting. Previously, I open it pressing down Option+CMD+R. I guess it is because there was no SSD. I connected to wifi and started the recovery. Just like previous times, it loaded something for 3-4 mins. Then Apple logo and progress bar showed up but it stuck again at the same place.


If I try to wipe the SSD and install Ubuntu, do you think I can install mac any time later? Would a successfull boot from USB install all the necessary partitions on the disk? I wanna use my machine as a computer, not necessarily as a mac, instead of throwing it into the bin.


This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

Macbook Pro Early 2015 (Intel) stuck at progress bar during Internet recovery and booting from USB Media

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.