arthurfromgreat barrington wrote:
. Seems I made the assumption that family sharing still meant all the participants needed there own apple id.
They do. Just trying to ascertain what you did.
I made one by giving him an icloud email address.
How? did you create a new iCloud account? How did you did this? Or did you create a iCloud email alias on your own account?
Seems he doesn't need one?
He does, Family Sharing works across different Apple IDs.
The other thing it seems is that music subscription itself needs to individually be a family or personal plan. By Family sharing, I thought all subscriptions or plans on my apple account would automatically be available to all family members..
Yes, for the Apple Music Subscription, it needs to be a Family to be sharable. The individual plan cannot be shared.
I will probably start by deleting the 10 year olds apple ID
No, don't do this. You should keep it, and it should be signed in on the devices he uses.
If you have an Apple Music Family Plan then he will have his own library on his devices, and will not affect your own.
Each person needs to have their own Apple ID, and can an Apple Music Family plan can be shared with them over Family Sharing.