Final Cut Pro timeline is suddenly glitchy on playback, seems corrupted

I've been working on a project in final cut for a few weeks. It's been working fine. I'm not sure if it's related, but tonight I imported some footage from a phone, into a new event. Then I started getting the spinning beach ball. This happened sometimes when I was placing still photos in the timeline, but I would simply quit FCP and restart, and things would be fine for a while.


Today though, after importing that media, the playback was very glitchy. The picture would freeze, but I'd hear the audio continuing. Or the audio would blank out for a few seconds, and then continue.


Seems like this is "corrupted" but I have no experience with trying to resolve such things. I've been using FCP 10.6.7


I've restarted my media server. I've restarted the computer. I've tried restoring library from back up. I keep getting the same issues. If the back ups are corrupted too, or you can't open a backup without it linking to the corrupted file, I'm not sure how to shake off this corrupted file. When I say file, I mean the project file to open the whole project: Library might be the more accurate term.


I'm a little worried since I don't know how to fix it. But I have faith this isn't the first time, and someone might have some suggestions.



iMac Pro, macOS 14.0

Posted on Feb 8, 2024 4:33 PM

Reply
Question marked as Top-ranking reply

Posted on Feb 22, 2024 4:53 PM

Booting off an external SSD with a fresh OS install allows you to confirm whether or not there are issues with the macOS installed on your iMac's internal drive. For this simple external SSD test just create a new user in the new OS and go from there. Install FCP, create a new library and import fresh media onto the external SSD.


Migration means using Apple's Migration Assistant to copy a System's info and Users from another computer, Time Machine backup or another backup drive. This is great when you buy a new machine and want to migrate yourself from your old machine to the new machine. The caveat is that it's best to only migrate User info, no Applications or System files.


Correct, just to rule things out, no disk encryption (FileVault) to make the test as straightforward as possible.


Ultimately the goal is to quickly take the iMac's currently installed macOS out of the equation to see if it's the problem.


If there was a bad drive in the Jellyfish that could also cause glitchy playback and random freezes.

Similar questions

55 replies

Feb 13, 2024 1:52 AM in response to JourneymanCanada

Just delete the FCP preferences as I described.


It won't take more than 10 seconds and may work. If it doesn't you have lost nothing . . . except 10 seconds.


Regarding Chrome, I have my doubts. Many respected members of this forum claim it is damaging to pro apps but on the 2 or 3 occasions I have installed it there has been zero impact on my editing . . . though I do not do a lot.


Furthermore on other forums I have seen many professionals who do a lot of intensive editing with Chrome installed and who have suffered no problems, so I feel the jury is still out on the matter.


I know the "Chrome is Bad" article looks pretty damning but the author can only have access to a handful of complaints compared to the millions who probably use FCP and other pro apps. So the conclusions deduced are based on anecdotal rather than scientifically assessed data with double-blind trials etc.

Feb 19, 2024 1:57 PM in response to JourneymanCanada

Matthew, the new admin user test is to determine if there might be something corrupt in your regular user space. That doesn't appear to be the case since you experienced the issues with a brand new user. The new Etrecheck report was to confirm that Chrome and its keystone software was truly removed and see if anything new popped up.


I too also experienced the "automatic" update to Sonoma on my iMac even after explicitly dismissing the dialog.


In a previous post you mentioned that while troubleshooting you determined that video playback was bad even outside of FCP. Was this on the internal drive or the Jellyfish? Is the Jellyfish/OWC driver current? Have you tried tests with no external devices connected? Has the boot drive always been encrypted?

Feb 9, 2024 1:26 PM in response to Tom Wolsky


Thanks for the patience and suggestions. I've attached the report as you outlined, thanks.


I tried Luis Sequeira1's suggestions to clear render files. I've played the timeline a bit, and so far so good, but there is one weird thing still happening on the timeline where a still photo image has become a block of grey, where there once was an image.


So I don't trust the stability of the timeline/Library just yet. I'm just beginning an edit session, hoping it's smooth.


note: Harddrive storage is at half of the 1TB capacity, so storage should not be causing issues.

Feb 9, 2024 2:12 PM in response to Luis Sequeira1

Thanks again, Luis. I read the website/blog on Chrome.


I didn't realize I'd have to delete Chrome completely, and not use it, to see if this helps.


Seems drastic. I'm quite integrated into the Chrome/Google suite ecosystem, with a million bookmarked pages, chrome extensions & tools, Calendar, Drive, Google meets, etc., ...so I hesitate to take such a dive off a cliff based on the say-so of this apparently nameless, facelesss blog post. Is it your post? Or did you read it and remove Chrome yourself, then just adapt to life without it, AND...did you notice a big difference?


thanks for any thoughts you can share on this!


Are you a Final Cut Pro user?

I'm still wondering if my file is corrupted. I used to have a team of editors who did all the troubleshooting like this. I just use FCP for rough-cutting as a director/producer. I'm not really an "editor" but I remember my editors talking about "corrupted files" in FCP. Since my company downsized, I don't have those editors anymore.

Appreciate your help. Cheers

Feb 10, 2024 4:08 AM in response to JourneymanCanada

I understand that as you are so into the Chrome ecosystem this is an issue.


I would then suggest that you have a separate mac for editing, and don't install Chrome in it.

Or perhaps install a separate copy of the OS on a separate volume.

We are used to seeing all sorts of trouble with video editing (also in Premiere) due not so much to Chrome itself but its poorly programmed background agents.


You can use Chrome without the keystone things. They are there ostensively to help keep Chrome up to date... but they run poorly and waste resources.





Feb 12, 2024 1:56 PM in response to Tom Wolsky

Fair question. I'm not a super-savvy browser user. I just assumed that if I was using the Google suite of apps (Calendar, gmail, Drive, etc.,) and had all my bookmarks and extensions, that I would lose all that unless I stuck with Chrome. But I was able to import bookmarks into Safari, as well as passwords, etc. And I realize that I have access to all the Google Suite thru Safari, now. I've gone ahead and removed Chrome and its support files, as per the "chromeisbad.com" website. I hope this is the solution and FCP stops being glitchy. I haven't had another edit session yet to be able to tell.


My FCP playback issue really looked to me like something in the FCP environment, and I've been cutting just fine with FCP, with Chrome on my machine, for a year, so I'm not sure what changed. Once I start editing again, I'll see quickly if the glitches are still there.


But you guys have been super helpful in making suggestions, and taking time to read my posts. Very much APPRECIATED! THANKS!

Feb 14, 2024 2:16 PM in response to Ian R. Brown

Thanks very much, Ian, for considering my case further, I really appreciate your time.

After purging my system of Chrome as it was recommended, I only got back to my edit today to see if the problem was gone. Unfortunately I'm having the same problem. Playback is inconsistent and glitchy.


As a variation on what you suggested, I loaded another project -- completely different media, finished project with lots of transitions, etc. -- and it plays back with the same problems. 


I tried deleting the FCP preferences. I opened my current project, and it still has the same problems.


So I've tried everyone's solutions here. Got rid of Chrome, tried a completely new project, deleted preferences, and FCP seems to have a problem now.


I welcome other suggestions. This is concerning!


thanks, Mathew 


Feb 19, 2024 1:26 PM in response to terryb

TerryB, thanks for the suggestions. I created a new admin user, fired up FCP and started to work with some clips in a new library.

Even the import process was prompting the beach ball spinning. Just looking for folders of media, opening folders, the beach ball would spin. Then when I had a few files into the library, I would try setting in and out points on some footage, and that would make the beach ball spin. Then trying to drag a selected clip to the timeline would get stuck (beach ball). I assembled a simple clip with a bit of interview, some cover footage and music, and the playback had the same glitchy playback as I've been experiencing.


My available disk space on my workstation is about 60% free. I've got lots of RAM, and to reiterate, I was editing just fine on this machine for the past 6 weeks. I don't edit everyday, but once I'm editing a project, it's every day. Except now I've been stalled 11 days on this issue.


What does this test help us understand? Does it eliminate some possibilities or suggest others, or lead to another dead end?! Thanks again for your time and suggestions. Mathew

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

Final Cut Pro timeline is suddenly glitchy on playback, seems corrupted

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.