Battery health percentage displayed on MacBook Air M1 is completely wrong.

I've owned a MacBook Air M1 2020 since new purchased from the Apple Amazon Store in 2021. It's been the single best all-round laptop I've used in 35 years of PC building and tinkering around with computers. It's been pretty much perfect...until recently when the battery life suddenly went off a cliff, losing some 30% of it's run time within a a few weeks, using the laptop as I have always done.


The M1 Air comes with a Non-removable 11.4v 49.9Wh (4,379 mAh) battery and my 'Battery Health' monitor in the Air states that the battery is performing 'Normally' and has 88% health. However, upon 10x full discharges and 100% charge cycles, the battery is only able to charge to an average of 2550mAh using a USB C charge meter that has proven itself to be trustworthy.


The battery has lost over 1,829 mAh of it's original capacity of 4,379. That's a hugely significant loss of 41% lost capacity. The battery health should be reading 58% health instead of 88%. So why is the battery health monitor showing this random 88% 'health' reading? It doesn't reflect the true condition of the battery at all.


I've still got AC+ cover for several months.


Thanks.

Posted on Feb 21, 2024 3:20 PM

Reply
Question marked as Top-ranking reply

Posted on Feb 26, 2024 7:02 AM

Run the third party app Coconut Battery and compare the results. Coconut Battery's information lines up with information I'm pulling from the macOS command line utility "ioreg".


FYI, you cannot always go by what is listed on websites for values that the battery is supposed to have. You need to retrieve the battery's Design Capacity directly from the battery itself. Apple does use multiple manufacturers for most of the parts used in their devices, so there is always a chance for something to be different.


I have never personally seen the large discrepancy you are reporting even when I'm stress testing a battery to get the Full Charge Capacity (FCC) to fluctuate the most to reveal just how low it will get. The most I've normally seen is about a 10% deviation of the FCC during my stress tests.


Keep in mind that Apple's battery information is not updated in real time....I'm not sure what triggers a refresh of the values. I know that even though I may trigger an extreme drop in FCC below the 77% to 80% that macOS does not always trigger a "Service Recommended" battery condition. I also know that when I reconnect the charger, many times the FCC value goes up above the 77% - 80% margin so that if I run the Apple Diagnostics no battery issue will be found.


Have you tried running the Apple Diagnostics to see if it reports any problems with the battery? Or taken it to an Apple Store or an Apple Authorized Service Provider to see what their service diagnostics report, or what they may have to say about the issue?


Similar questions

6 replies
Question marked as Top-ranking reply

Feb 26, 2024 7:02 AM in response to Rod Fountain

Run the third party app Coconut Battery and compare the results. Coconut Battery's information lines up with information I'm pulling from the macOS command line utility "ioreg".


FYI, you cannot always go by what is listed on websites for values that the battery is supposed to have. You need to retrieve the battery's Design Capacity directly from the battery itself. Apple does use multiple manufacturers for most of the parts used in their devices, so there is always a chance for something to be different.


I have never personally seen the large discrepancy you are reporting even when I'm stress testing a battery to get the Full Charge Capacity (FCC) to fluctuate the most to reveal just how low it will get. The most I've normally seen is about a 10% deviation of the FCC during my stress tests.


Keep in mind that Apple's battery information is not updated in real time....I'm not sure what triggers a refresh of the values. I know that even though I may trigger an extreme drop in FCC below the 77% to 80% that macOS does not always trigger a "Service Recommended" battery condition. I also know that when I reconnect the charger, many times the FCC value goes up above the 77% - 80% margin so that if I run the Apple Diagnostics no battery issue will be found.


Have you tried running the Apple Diagnostics to see if it reports any problems with the battery? Or taken it to an Apple Store or an Apple Authorized Service Provider to see what their service diagnostics report, or what they may have to say about the issue?


Feb 29, 2024 2:38 PM in response to HWTech

Thank you, HWTech for your considered reply.


In the last few days I have been using Coconut and Battery Health 2 apps to monitor the battery charge and discharge cycles. I have also been using my USB C battery charge monitor (in-line with the USB C charging cable) to minitor and tally results with what the OS is reporting. Results are conflicting.


The only reason I am here asking this question is because I noticed a sudden and significant drop in battery performance one day a few weeks ago after a couple of years of superb performance. Battery life 'felt' like it had dropped off by 40-50% from one week to the next after 2 years. So I started monitiring the mAh charge into the battery and immediately found that the battery was only takinh 2550mAh to charge from 1% to 100%. I have now repeated this 4 times and I have nearly identical results around the 2550mAh number.


Apple's literature states that this M1 Air shipped with a 4,379 mAh battery and my monitoring software (Coconut and Battery Health 2) states the 'original max' of my battery capacity to be 4,382 mAh. The software also states that the current maximum charge is 4001 mAh. So, a 381mAh reduction over the original capacity. This works out to about a 9% drop in capacity. Apple's software is reporting 88% battery 'health' - whatever than means, or a 12% drop in capacity.


However, over USB C, using the power monitor, I have consistantly only managed to measure a maximum charge capacity of 2550 mAh from flat to 100% - over a 40% capacity drop from new. I have to say, the 40% drop in capacity is far more in line with my experience of this battery suddenly loosing so much capacity in everyday use. I wouldn't have been motivated to look for explanations over an incremental 10-20% drop over time.


So, my conclusions are that the OS software is not reporting the truth. The battery has lost much more capacity than advertised and that battery 'health' is far lower that 88% in real life.


Unfortunately, I live 1.5hrs away from a 'genius' bar and my issue isn't straightforward to explain or demonstrate without having several hours to kill and a power meter. I am still will full Apple+ care coverage for a few more months but I have no idea when I'll be able to get to an Apple store and I have little enthusiasm to be lectured to my a 'Genius' about battery life and how the OS says it's healthy at 88%. I'll try and write to Apple directly for an explanation of the battery health discrepancy I am experiencing.


Many thanks.



Feb 26, 2024 5:44 AM in response to HWTech

Wikipedia, Apple's own website, MacRumours...any website really, they all state the same capacity; 49.9Wh and 4379 mAh capacity. I am measuring the current battery charge capacity using a USB C tester power meter that is accurate. The difference between Apple's OS stated 88% battery health and the actual 58% of original capacity, is vast. Am I missing something? I know Apple are obliged to replace the battery under warranty if it drops below 80% 'health' within my warranty period...

Feb 29, 2024 9:11 PM in response to Ruskes

The battery is under 3 years old. I understand how and why batteries degrade - what this post is about, is trying to understand why Apple software is reporting the battery to be in good health at 88% capacity, when it is very clearly not. It's more like 60%.


It's 'convenient' that the battery will only be replaced under warranty with Apple Care+ if it drops below 80% health within the warranty period.

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

Battery health percentage displayed on MacBook Air M1 is completely wrong.

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.