Why the duplicate Applications folders and which one(s) can I trash?

I've tried to disregard the duplicate Applications folders on my HD and double Mail programs in my dock but would like to trash any I don't need (I'm the only user of my machine). I see that there's an Applications folder in my HD icon (under "Devices"); an Applications folder in my Finder window (under "Places"), and an Applications folder accessible by clicking on my name in the Finder window (also under "Places"). Although it appears there are 3 Applications folders / Mail programs, a search in Finder suggests there are actually 2: one is traceable to HD (hard disk); the other is traceable to my name. Which of these is "safe" to trash? (I don't understand why my Finder must contain two Applications folders--frequently resulting in the appearance of duplicate Mail programs in my dock. Any clarification/suggestions appreciated. Cap

iMac 2.4 GHz Intel, Mac OS X (10.6.4)

Posted on Aug 24, 2010 8:07 AM

Reply
13 replies

Aug 24, 2010 8:22 AM in response to Cap

None, they appear to be all the same just different accesses. Folders in the Finder's sidebar are just aliases to the real folders. You can drag files and folders into the Finder's sidebar for convenient access. You can also remove them by simply selecting them and dragging them out of the Finder window and over the Desktop. Then release and they 'poof' away. You can change where a sidebar item is positioned in the sidebar by selecting it and repositioning it within the sidebar. You can also select certain items to appear or not in the Finder's sidebar by selecting Preferences from the Finder's Finder menu. Click on the Sidebar icon in the toolbar. Use the checkboxes to enable or disable display of the items listed.

If you have a duplicate application in your Dock, as you have described with regards to Mail, then select the icon and quickly drag it out of the Dock. It should 'poof' away.

Sep 3, 2010 4:54 PM in response to Kappy

Thanks, that's helpful. And I'm convinced that at least 1 of the 3 appearances of a program in my Finder window is an alias. But I'm still puzzled by the following: When I click on a program that's in my "Macintosh HD" (under "Devices" in the Finders column), it opens up the program (e.g. iPhoto) that's on my dock--and in the condition I left it. However, when I click on the iPhotos icon that's listed further down, in the exposed Applications folder under "Places," the result is a second iPhotos icon appearing at the extreme right on my dock (when I open this 2nd program I'm taken through the process as though I hadn't used the program). The same occurs when I click on my name in the finder window and access iPhotos from there. In other words, I'm constantly seeing two versions of the same program on my dock, making me ultra cautious about which is the real deal. I guess if I simply click on the program that's in my dock, I can ignore the duplicate icon problem. Cap

Sep 3, 2010 6:13 PM in response to Cap

The Applications folder displayed by clicking on your Macintosh HD item under Devices in the sidebar is your real Applications folder. Under Places is an alias to the Applications folder or it should be. I suggest dragging that item out of the sidebar, then locate your Applications folder and drag it into the sidebar under Places.

I'm not sure why anything you click on in the sidebar should appear in the Dock. The only things that appear on the right side of the Dock are the Trash icon and any smart folders placed in the Dock such as Applications, Downloads, and Documents which are generally created by the OS X default installation.

Sep 8, 2010 7:15 PM in response to Kappy

Thanks. That helps me with the concept, and I see that there can only be one "real" Applications folder which is under Devices and labeled Macintosh HD. Perhaps what I'm trying to say is that the below that, in the Places area, the programs in the "Applications" of my "Home Folder" (the little house followed by my name) don't agree with the programs in the "Applications" folder right underneath it. The latter Applications Folder agrees with the one on my Hard Drive, it has the new iTunes program, etc. whereas the programs in the Applications Folder of my Home Folder are different (the old iTunes program, etc.). I guess I'm saying that the Applications Folders of my Hard Drive and of my Home Folder are at odds. I'm simply going to try following your idea--drag the Applications Folder from my Home Folder onto the desktop, replace it with the Applications Folder from my Hard Drive, then go through the eternity of trashing the old Home Folder Applications Folder
that will by now be copied on my Desktop. (Wish I new of a faster way of trashing the many programs.) I'll let you know if it works. Thanks again, Cap

Sep 8, 2010 7:23 PM in response to Cap

The Home folder (the little house icon) is not an alias to the Applications folder, it's an alias to your Home folder. There are no applications in the Home folder. It's used for data storage - Documents, Downloads, Movies, Music, Pictures, and Sites. Additionally there's a Public folder used to exchange files with other users on your computer; and a Library folder user to store special files used by other software but which the account owner has access.

I think you are confusing the Home and Applications folders as being identical. If there's an Applications folder inside your Home folder it would have been for applications you've chosen not to install for others to use, so you did not install them in the system Applications folder.

Sep 8, 2010 8:03 PM in response to Kappy

Kappy, as always, you are the man.

But I was always under the impression that there are two Applications Folders, one under "My iMac (Computer)" and one under the Home Folder. I thought that if one looked in the Home Folder by default one would find an Application Folder, whether there is anything in it or not. All my apps are under "My iMac" except for a small Creative Suite Installer program which is in the Application Folder of my Home Folder.

I only bring this to your attention because you make the statement "There are no applications in the Home Folder." As far as I can tell there is an Application Folder that resides there by default, and I don't think it is unusual for there to be applications located there. I can understand how one person on a multi-user computer may not want a particular program available to all users.

I am wondering if the original poster may be having issues because he has applications located in the two different App Folders, with some possible duplicates.

This entire thread is making my head spin.

Arch

Sep 8, 2010 8:13 PM in response to Arch Riker

Never seen an Applications folder inside the Home folder except for an older version os OS X that did put one in the Home folder during installation. I suppose if you updgraded from that version it may have preserved it.

I do not have a DVD that installs 10.6.4 directly, so if this is something added since 10.6, then I have missed it. I must upgrade which will not install anything non-default for the basic system version I must start from.

Sep 8, 2010 9:06 PM in response to Kappy

Kappy, as I said, it has always been my "impression" that there are two default Application Folders. I based that "impression" on the fact that one can install applications for systemwide use or only in one's Home Folder. I figured that if you can install an app in the Home Folder, then there must be a default App Folder there. Like I said, my Home Folder has an App Folder, so I assumed everyone's does. Of course my Home Folder App Folder actually has an application inside it, so maybe that is why the App Folder is there, and not that it is there by default. I just checked my Cube running Panther and there is no App Folder in the Home Folder. So you are most likely correct. As usual.

But I still wonder whether the OP hasn't installed Apps in his Home Folder. But my head is spinning so fast now that I just no longer care.

Good luck to all.

Arch

Sep 10, 2010 9:10 PM in response to Kappy

I think you may have nailed my misconception. Indeed, I was expecting the Home Folder to mirror the contents and behavior of any programs in my Application folder and its aliases. If it has the special function and contents you mention, that explains my confusion and re-focuses me on the one Applications folder I need be concerned with. In fact, if the Home Folder continues to plague me, I may simply "poof" it by dragging it outside the Finder window, at least until I become more proficient with using the Finder window. (I think it was the MacWorld Basic Guide that emphasized "mastery" of the Finder window as the key to being in harmony with the whole system.) I've been so busy "using" Macs, I haven't invested sufficient time in "understanding" them. As a result of this discussion I certainly won't confuse the Applications Folder and the Home Folder anymore--or, for that matter, the Finder and Spotlight!

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

Why the duplicate Applications folders and which one(s) can I trash?

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.