I understand that I made a choice when I opted not to purchase AppleCare. The debate over the value of extended warranties is indeed subjective; some view them as essential, while others see them as a way for companies to boost revenue from their products.
While $69 seems like a reasonable price to replace a small watch screen without AppleCare, I believe that generally repair costs should not be so close to the cost of replacement. From a consumer perspective, it feels disproportionate.
I recognize that Apple’s ecosystem is compelling, and from a business standpoint, their pricing strategy is effective. Despite my frustration, I’m unlikely to switch to another platform as I don't see a superior alternative on the horizon.
On a positive note, there was a recent software update, so this could potentially be a software-related issue that might resolve itself. Support didn’t indicate any known issues, but I’ll keep an eye on it. If the problem persists, I’ll consider a replacement in the fall.