Wallet and Apple Pay under system settings shows old emails with no option to delete in dropdown menu.

I am using a MacBook Air M2 with macOS Sonoma 14.6.1. This is my first macOS device. I had iPhones prior to 2019, but currently have an S10+. I will be switching to an iPhone 16 Pro Max when it ships in a couple weeks.

Thank you for the suggestion.

I can't find anything referencing me beside My Card in contacts, which doesn't have any of the associated emails. If I search for the old email addresses in contacts, nothing comes back, but if I search for any other emails, it yields the associated contact card. I've checked Apple ID as well.

Maybe I can only do it when I get the iPhone? I'll attach a screenshot of the emails I can't get rid of. The only one that should be there is RoryM***@gmail.com. Even the duplicate I made when trying to overwrite it seems stuck there forever.

[Edited by Moderator]

Once I click the gear icon on the task bar to open system settings, I am presented with the list of system settings categories. In this screenshot, I clicked Wallet & Apple Pay, which is why the back button is highlighted. Closing and reopening system settings always defaults to the Appearance category.

There is no edit button I can find anywhere. I have also tried clicking the selections with every modifier key or using the delete key.

I have tried every combination of modifier key as well as right click on both the category of Wallet & Apple Pay, as well as on the email addresses in the dropdown list. They have no effect.

I'll see if I can find an opportunity to try that and report back.