FCPX 11 120fps transcoded clips doesnt show slow motion controls

FCPX 11 120fps transcoded clips doesnt show slow motion controls, until FCPX 10.8 (included) you could transcoded clips to 120fps and keep the slow motin controls in QtX


With FCPX 11:


With previous versions:


Just wondering if it is a new feature and I'm missing the option to change it, or if it is a new bug.


Clips from FCXP11 keep the 120fps but the only option in QtX is to play them at 0.5x. Maybe they are played at 60fps because the screen is 60Mhz and its a new feature? so old 120 fps clips are played at 30fps/30Mhz no matter the speed you choose?


(Original clips are from iPhone, and I'm editing and merging them in FC since few years ago, transcoded retain the same properties and fps as the originals, so you can later play them as intended by Apple or edit them as I please in different projects)



Posted on Feb 27, 2025 2:09 AM

Reply
3 replies
Sort By: 

Feb 27, 2025 12:30 PM in response to guguii

iOS/iPadOS 18 introduced QuickTime FullFrameRatePlaybackIntent tag:


"key that represents whether this movie should play at full frame rate


Some apps play movies recorded at frame rates of 120fps or higher in slow motion. If your app records high-frame-rate movies, you can add this movie-level metadata to indicate whether the movie intends to play at the full frame rate (1) or at a slow motion rate (0). Apps that play movies may use this metadata, when present, to guide their behavior."


quickTimeMetadataKeyFullFrameRatePlaybackIntent | Apple Developer Documentation


macOS 15 Sequoia QuickTime Player plays middle part of high frame rate movies (seems to be ≈85 fps or more) in slow-motion without that tag (earlier macOS like Ventura seem to behave the same).


For example, losslessly convert an existing 25 fps .mov video to 250 fps (25/250=0.1) and delete audio:


ffmpeg -itsscale 0.1 -i input.mov -c copy -an output.mov


The whole movie plays at 250 fps in Sequoia after adding or editing:


exiftool -m -P -overwrite_original -api LargeFileSupport=1 -ext mov -Keys:FullFrameRatePlaybackIntent=1 output.mov


Back to the default slow-motion behavior:


exiftool -m -P -overwrite_original -api LargeFileSupport=1 -ext mov -Keys:FullFrameRatePlaybackIntent=0 output.mov


Or just delete FullFrameRatePlaybackIntent tag:


exiftool -m -P -overwrite_original -api LargeFileSupport=1 -ext mov -Keys:FullFrameRatePlaybackIntent= output.mov


BTW it seems currently Windows might be incompatible. If that tag is present, Windows might fail to display thumbnails and most metadata items in its Details panel (Media created, resolution, frame rate, audio details etc).


If that tag causes problems in Windows, you might remove it from all .mov movies in a folder with (the dot in the and means the folder you are currently in -- alternatively you can replace it with the path to that folder):


exiftool -m -P -overwrite_original -api LargeFileSupport=1 -ext mov -Keys:FullFrameRatePlaybackIntent= .


https://exiftool.org/forum/index.php?topic=16824.0


Reply

Feb 27, 2025 2:23 AM in response to guguii

The original clips from iPhone are the ones where you have these slow motion controls. I think that you are mistaking those from clips exported out of FCP.


10.8.1 cannot even create projects at 120fps - it tops out at 60fps.


Also: a 120fps is not a slomo movie, it is a high frame rate movie. The point is to record enough frames so that you can do slow motion, in a standard frame rate like 30fps, with best quality. For example, a 120fps clip played at 25% speed in a 30fps will use all the recorded frames.



Reply

Mar 3, 2025 8:26 AM in response to Luis Sequeira1

Hi Luis, thanks for the clearance.


It is possible to export/transcoded edited clips (not projects) at 120fps or 240fps from FC and Compressor, as I said in my OP I've been doing for years.

The only change FC11 introduced is this new behaviour, as Matti Haveri suggested seems to be due to this new "tag" thing in OS.


So it's not clear if it is a new feature/behaviour but to me looks like it is something FC11 is missing from previous versions.

Reply

FCPX 11 120fps transcoded clips doesnt show slow motion controls

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.