How to have overdue assignments that repeat daily not skip a day?

I have a few reminders that are used more like daily to-do lists and repeat every day. The issue is if I forgot to mark them as completed the day before or if I actually didn't do them, they show up as overdue (which is fine), but then when I complete them the next day it marks is as complete for the current day, not the previous one. And then it changes the due date to be tomorrow instead of today.

Before clicking done:

After clicking done:

Have to manually update due date to today instead:

Thanks!