Hulu on one Apple TV asks for sign-in
I'm been paying for Hulu via Apple for years. Just recently when I access Hulu from AppleTV, or even try to continue watching a show, Hulu is asking me to sign in. This also is only happening on one of my Apple TV boxes. On another Apple TV it works fine. I've tried restarting the Apple TV and deleting and reinstalling the Hulu app. I'm not subscribed to Disney+ but I do have a ESPN+ account which is also paid through Apple.
Apple TV 4K (3rd generation)