Really Bob? It is not about AFP being removed, this is about the entire Apple user experience. The vast majority of Mac users are not technically astute, they are everyday people who purchased an easier to use computer than those offered by manufacturers using Microsoft OS. Personally, after 35 years with Microsoft OS I switched to Mac because it was so much simpler to maintain. It just worked, and worked well. I would be having this same conversation with Microsoft if they had removed support for a fundamental data transport protocol. Yes HW and Its associated SW gets deprecated, that is usually progress - a good thing! My overarching concern is for other Mac users who were caught unaware the same way I was. My objection is simply that a change of this magnitude should have been better communicated in a “Read me First” notice. That is what I would have expected from Apple.
I cut my teeth on IBM mainframes, Unix mini’s and IBM PC’s. My first ever computer was a preproduction IBM XT from IBM’s labs. I have over 50 years working with computers and as such know full well the value of clear and concise communication.
I think that gives me some credence when I write about support issues.