SchmuFoo wrote:
For Protocol:
Same problem here with ATV 2nd Gen connected via HDMI to an Onkyo TX-SR 606, even when using the Optical SPDIF Port.
ATV is configured with German Language.
No matter of Dolby Digital is Auto or On.
I originally encoded for downloading my videos to my PS3. At the time the PS3 did not support AC3-passthrough and I encoded them all as 6 channel ACC. They played fine with full 5.1 in the PS3. Later a PS3 firmware update included AC3 passthrough and I started encoding using passthrough.
I feed my ATV2 to my Onkyo SR-705 via HDMI (both optical inputs are taken, one by an XBox 360 and one by the PS3). I find that none of my AAC encoded videos will play with 5.1 audio in the ATV2 and all of the ones encoded with AC3 passthrough will play 5.1.
I used Mediainfo Mac to examine the differences and I found that I had set the audio bit rate to 320kbps. As the ATV2 supports 6 channel AAC from 16kbps to 320kbps and mine was encoded at 320kbps I find it strange that my AAC encoded 6-channel videos will not play in 5.1 using the ATV2. I'll be re-encoding them with AC3 passthrough as the simplest 'fix'.
I didn't have to change anything in my ATV2 setup, my Onkyo detected the 5.1 from the AC3 passthrough with the default settings on my ATV2.
I may try experimenting with encoding with 6 channel AAC at other than the full 320kbps bit rate just to see how that plays out.
Message was edited by: crh24