Can someone recommend some good speakers for iMac?

Hello everyone,

I have had my new iMac for about a month and I love it. I am looking for some quality speakers for it now. I would say my price range would be $200. I will use them for watching movies, playing music, as well as I am starting to get into garage band as well and make songs, although they aren't that good at the moment. I figured this was the right forum to come to, it seems everyone is very knowledgable to music and sound. So, can someone recommend some great speakers for me? I am leaning towards a desktop setup, and are there any that make use of the built in optical audio output on the imac? Thank you all for your help.

-Matt

iMac G5 (isight), Mac OS X (10.4.3), 20 inch / 2.1 ghz / 1 gig RAM/ ATi 600XT

Posted on Dec 7, 2005 10:37 PM

Reply
45 replies

Dec 8, 2005 5:38 AM in response to brewcrew79

Good studio monitors will cost a bit more than that, especially if you want powered ones. But if you are just getting started with making music, you may want to look at these http://www.m-audio.com/products/en_us/LX421System-main.html Someone in the Logic Express forum suggested them to me, though he did not have them himself. Alos, check out Sweetwater.com They have a ton of monitors in all price ranges.

Dec 10, 2005 7:44 AM in response to brewcrew79

Sure! Mine are the only set of speakers on my desk. The Edirol MA-10D have two line inputs, so you can hook-up you second computer or soundcard to it too -- I use the second input to monitor my mixer before it hits the computer.
THe way I see it, if you drop a load of cash on some speakers/monitors, you should be able to listen to whatever you darn well like through it.

happy shopping.

Dec 17, 2005 7:55 PM in response to Scott Laughlin-Richard

It seems brewcrew79 is looking for speakers versatile enough for music AND movies. The Klipsch ProMedia 2.1 and the Altec Lansing MX-5021 systems are both 2.1 THX certified (good for movies). All movies have music in them.

Small studio monitors are intended for nearfield monitoring (no more than 3-4 feet from the ears in a triangular configuration measuring one meter on each side of an equilateral triangle consisting of a left speaker, a right speaker, and a human head). Small nearfield studio monitors will not provide the earth-shaking bass that a subwoofer produces.

For movies and music, a system with a subwoofer is a must (a 2.1 system = 2 satellite speakers + 1 subwoofer). The Klipsch ProMedia 2.1 system outspecs ALL other computer speaker systems by comparison.

Dec 17, 2005 8:17 PM in response to brewcrew79

I just bought my 20' 2.1 Ghz G5 iMac... and I have my complete CD collection in it (almost 4000 songs)... inside iTunes. I wanted to get a great pair of powered speakers to enjoy my music with... using Airport Express w/ AirTunes. I bought some Logitech THX Z-5300e speakers (at BestBuy)... 5 smaller speakers with 1 bass speaker. They sound great! With a 10% discount.. they cost me $202.. that's including taxes!
If you get these speakers.. they're for 5.1 surround sound, too... which isn't compatible with my iMac.. since the iMac is only 2 channel.. There'll be 3 wires plugged into the back of the bass speaker... so just plug the center wire into the Airport Express that is plugged into the wall. That will make it compatible with 2 channel.
I'm totally happy with these speakers! Great bass! Great quality sound! I really hate BestBuy, cuz they're so anti-Apple... but I had to use a $20 gift certificate.. so I used it on the speakers.

Dec 17, 2005 9:35 PM in response to Scott Laughlin-Richard

In the original post, brewcrew79 specified a $200 price range. The M-Audio Studiophile LX4 2.1 system retails for $280 (12/05). At $150 (12/05) the Klipsch ProMedia 2.1 system were more affordable than the M-Audio.

The frequency response of the Klipsch system is 31Hz-20kHz; the M-Audio system is 40Hz-20kHz.

You need a bass frequency response of at least 30Hz to hear the low B string on a 5-string bass, or feel the Moog Taurus bass pedals on Genesis' Selling England by the Pound, on Renaissance's Live at Carnegie Hall version of "Ashes Are Burning," and on the Yes' CD, Magnification.

The Klipsch sub has better bass response than the M-Audio sub.

The Klipsch system amplifier outputs 55 watts power at ≤ 1% THD for each satellite speaker; the M-Audio only 27 watts.

The Klipsch system amplifier outputs 50 watts @ ≤ 7% THD + 200 watts of burst power at ≤ 1% THD for the subwoofer; the M-Audio outputs 60 watts for the sub. M-Audio does not list their THD (total harmonic distortion) specs.

The average THD for computer speaker systems is 10% THD.

The Klipsch are a better system spec-wise and have a lower retail price than the M-Audio system.

How speakers "sound" is subjective, in the ear of the beholder.

POSTSCRIPT: I am not putting down M-Audio gear. I own several quality M-Audio products and use them in my studios.

Dec 18, 2005 10:15 AM in response to Stump

I guess the real question would be, "How serious are you and how serious do you think you will be about producing music in GB?"

If you say that you are as serious or more serious, or even think you will be, about producing music in GB as you are listening to music and watching movies, my recommendation would be for the M-Audio LX4 system previously recommended or a comparable monitoring system. If you are just playing around with GB and you don't think you will ever be relatively serious about the music you produce, I would recommend a consumer system, like the Klipsch system or something comparable.

While the Klipsch system and other comparable systems look better in terms of specs and may even "sound better," those specs may not be judged on the same plane. Klipsch may go down to 31hz but it may also be at -18dB (can't say for sure because I don't know if Klipsch publishes their frequency response). The M-Audio system or something comparable that is intended for studio monitoring should be within + or - 3 to 5dB of all other frequencies in their published frequency range. In fact, they will probably produce 31hz as the Klipsch system does but it will be much lower than the 40hz published.

Dec 18, 2005 4:34 PM in response to Silas

If you are SERIOUS about producing music, you would be using Logic Pro 7 and not GarageBand.

There is a difference between PRODUCING music and REproducing music as reflected by two different categories of speaker system.

First, nearfield studio monitors like the M-Audio LX4 system are for PRODUCING music in an acoustically neutral room like the control room of a recording studio, because they have a relatively flat frequency response, including the subwoofer.

Nearfield monitors are designed to be configured in an equilateral triangle measuring one meter on each side (monitor/monitor/human head) and the orientation and placement of studio monitors are critical to hear them properly.

Second, speaker systems for REproducing music on the other hand tend to color the sound by enhancing the bass frequencies and exciting the treble frequencies for the less than acoustically perfect home listening environment. The placement of this type of speaker is not as critical.

The two types of speaker systems are as different as apples and oranges.

Given that Paul Klipsch designed innovative speaker systems for 54 years (1946-2000), M-Audio is a relative newcomer.

Klipsch is very GarageBand friendly. They even feature GarageBand songs on their website homepage.

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

Can someone recommend some good speakers for iMac?

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.