macbook air fan noise

okay so i've JUST bought my new macbook air, i've had it for about 3 days now, been working fine, haven't been hearing anything from the fan... today i turned it on and realised that the fan was making quite a noticeable sound.. i was wondering if that was normal??

macbook air 11" late 2010, Mac OS X (10.6.4), also have macbook pro 15"

Posted on Oct 30, 2010 4:46 PM

Reply
151 replies

Dec 11, 2010 2:21 AM in response to Community User

Other Macbook Air 11.6, same story - extremely annoying buzzing sound in idle, coming from the upper left corner of the MBAs keyboard, where the fan is situated. Its more than just annoying - its distracting.

Haven't recognized the problem the first few days I was working on it, but since yesterday - it stays present.

Tweaking the Fanspeed does nothing, because the low Limit of 2000 seems to be set in the bios, I wasnt able to undercut it in Terminal.

Now what. I bought a 1000+ Euro Noisemoster - and am waiting on a Bios fix, or a statement on if it can be fixed by replacing the fan.

Others who might experience this problem, please get vocal.

Nov 4, 2018 12:08 PM in response to harlekinrains

I confirm that it's very distracting.

I don't think that the sound could be deleted with a bios update. Apple must change the fan to delete it. I hope they will propose a change program.

Dec 12, 2010 11:04 AM in response to Community User

Upon playing around a little to get to know the origin of the noise, and looking into the iFixit disassembly reports, I can now describe the problem in more detail.

First, the very high pitched humming noise, does originate from the fan. But this noise alone is not the problem, as it is almost not audible at a normal working distance - its the amplification this noise gets by the hollow case build structure, that becomes a resonating body for it, that makes this worse.

When I lay down the Macbook on a firm, but soft surface, the case part stops resonating, and the level of the humming reduces by about 70%, down to a level, where it isn't such a problem anymore.

I can reproduce the same effect by sitting down the Macbook Air at the upper left corner on my open palm, and then removing it. the character of the sound changes, the humming becomes a deeper and more full bodied.

http://www.ifixit.com/Teardown/MacBook-Air-11-Inch-Model-A1370-Teardown/3745/1

As you can see in the pictures, there is nothing that would stop the vibrations of the fan from setting the whole lower part of the Macbook in motion, as they are fixed only on the edge - Apple created a wonderfull "echo-chamber" for the little, but nevertheless noisy fan, which rotates at 2000 rpm even in idle.

What engineer in their right mind would create something like this? Too much confidence in the vibration resistance of a thin sheet of aluminium?

Again, please let us know, if you are also experiencing this problem - its hard to see this thread getting buried, by all other sorts of nonsense questions, and fanboys acting like here has bee an second coming of some sort...

I find it appalling, that almost everytime the first reaction to a problem here is someone who is trying to convince others, that

a. the problem doesn't exist
b. the problem lies with the individual
c. that it has been a design compromise, because Apple couldn't have done it differently

If this is the "Apple-experience", I know where to look for my next purchases...

Dec 12, 2010 11:03 AM in response to Jose Coelho

Again, one of those answers....

The problem has nothing to do with workload. It persists, even when the Macbook is in idle. There is no stress on the CPU, and in fact there is nothing but the OS counting threads in the background. The fan isn't even spinning up, it is at its lowest possible setting (2000 rpm).

Its a design misstep of the bigger kind... If my opinion is wanted.

Dec 12, 2010 2:08 PM in response to Community User

What is amazing is that Apple just removed a post I published saying I should take care where to spend my money. Let's see if they will remove this one too. Now we have a censorship in this discussion thread. So, you can only publish comments in favor of Apple. What a shame!!! See what they say. I did not write anything bad or that could be considered offensive.....

Apple removed your post on Apple Discussions titled "Re: macbook air fan noise" because it contained the following:

* Off-topic or non-technical posts

* Non-constructive rants or complaints

Dec 12, 2010 5:24 PM in response to jamestrent12

Seems problems like these with the Macbook Airs are not new...

http://forums.macrumors.com/showthread.php?t=347544

Well too bad that Apple now uses those propriatery 5 star torx screws - I might have fixed it by now... Or at least would be a step further.

So all I can get from this is, that the problem is more widespread, than previously thought, it was known even before the new Airs went in production and still Apple is instructing their support line staff to tell people it has to do with taxing their Macbook Airs "too much" as "they were not intended for workrelated tasks" -

This by the way was what was deleted from this thread - in a perfectly reasonable posting, which did not violate the forum rules in any way, I've read it, when Jose Coelho posted it and since wondered, why it wasn't here anymore.

Honestly how much do we users and customers have to escalate this matter, before we get a response? This thread already has more views than the ominous "I get a black screen (shutdown) from sleep mode" which is easily fixed by a simple SMC and PRAM reset.

I have the feeling, that there are several users in this thread, who won't simply let this "slide away", once again.

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

macbook air fan noise

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.