iPad 2 Smart Cover Design Flaw

You really don't get it do you, most people (myself included) would not place our Ipads in the sort of environment whereby screen damaging objects can contaminate the SmartCover.

I already stated I would use a napkin as a barrier, alternatively the napkin could be used to actually wipe up the mess first. If its too bad or just not possible for whatever reason I just would put my Ipad down whether it had a SmartCover or not.

If you are still not convinced buy a screen protector but please stop bashing an Apple accessory using what I consider to be a totally flawed logic.

I believe the SmartCover does exactly what it was designed for very well and the design should be applauded not condemned.

Interestingly, in this thread people are grumbling about marks on the OUTSIDE of their SmartCover, if you had your way that thread would be a lot longer!

http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?threadID=2801428&tstart=0&start=15

I think its a great design and enables me to prop the Ipad at an angle when I use it on my lap.

Regardless of which way the thing folds and which side mops up the food etc I would not put my Ipad (with or without SmartCover) down on a dirty table etc.

If push came to shove I would use a paper napkin as a temporary barrier!

However, hasn't anyone noticed that when you fold the Smart Cover into either of the two propping positions that the inner portion of the cover (the micro-fiber that supposed to "protect" the screen) comes in contact with whatever surface it is that you're using as a base. So, when you fold the cover back onto the iPad, any nastiness (e.g., dirt, dust, food, etc.) that was on the surface of the base (e.g., table, desk, airplane fold-out tray, etc.) has now attached to the inner portion of the cover and will then be in direct contact with your iPad's precious screen.

The same is true of the cover for the original iPad.

At the end of the day, why would you be putting the iPad or its cover into food or dirt ?

It takes an extra moment of thought, but my Smart cover can be folded either direction and still can be used in the two positions. But as others note, I would never set my iPad down on any surface that I had not checked to see if it was clean. Just as I do not use it with dirty fingers or hands.

I think that folks are expecting much more from a Smart Cover than it was actually designed to meet. It is for protecting the display, and incidentally was given the ability to hold the iPad in the two display positions. But it is only a cover, it is not a case. If you need the facilities of an actual case, this is not the product for you. It was made to apply and remove in a second. It facilitates its application by self-adjusting its position with the magnets.

But I am happy with mine as a cover to protect the glass display when not in use and nothing more. I remove the cover when I use the iPad. I have bough the Compass tripod stand by 12 South for positioning the iPad for serious use. I love using it with my Apple BT keyboard when I am using it for serious writing. However, for casual use like lounging in a comfy chair or in bed to read, surf or watch videos, I use it without the cover or anything else. If I am watching videos it is paired with BT headphones for the audio channel.

Rather than finding all the flaws of each accessory that does not meet your needs, why not look for the ones that other geniuses have devised that perhaps do?

You can fold the iPad smart cover so that the microfiber remains in the inside of the stand, just fold the cover open so that it's flat with microfiber facing up, then it's easy to fold into the stand with the microfiber on the inside. However, although this works, when using the stand in what I don't know how to describe as anything other than 'movie mode', the stand isn't very strong at all and can unfold at the slightest touch.

Especially to those that don't operate their iPads in a completely dust, dirt and grime-free environment, or if they don't have the time or inclination to meticulously check every work surface where they place their iPads before propping it up.

People who don't take time to ensure the surface is clean

a) risk scratching the rear of the iPad
b) have only themselves to blame for any damage

there really isn't a reason not to check a table doesn't have tea, food or sharp content on it.

please stop bashing an Apple accessory

Didn't see anyone "bashing".
Simply that the inside of the cover, which is designed with microfiber to "clean the screen whenever you open and close it" is on the outside setting on the table (or wherever).
Microfiber is designed to pick up dust.

Sure you likely wipe off a surface if it's grungy but I highly doubt you go around and scrub everything before you set your iPad down.

You would not use a cleaning cloth to wipe your desk/table (even after you wiped it down) then clean your glasses or television…
Why do it with the iPad cover?

Steven,

If you want to prop the iPad up, try this.

Lay the smart cover against the back of the iPad. Take the free side and lift it forward and fold it so it makes the 'propping' triangle. The outside will be the leather or vinyl and the microfiber will be on the inside and protected.

*What is Apple Discussions and how can it help me?*
Apple Discussions is a user-to-user support forum where experts and other Apple product users get together to discuss Apple products. You'll find a wealth of information about your favorite Apple hardware and software products that will help you get the most out of your purchase. You can participate in discussions about various products and topics, find solutions to help you resolve issues, ask questions, get tips and advice, and more.