Want to highlight a helpful answer? Upvote!

Did someone help you, or did an answer or User Tip resolve your issue? Upvote by selecting the upvote arrow. Your feedback helps others! Learn more about when to upvote >

Looks like no one’s replied in a while. To start the conversation again, simply ask a new question.

SSD Invalid node structure on MBP 4,1

Hi,


I have an early-2008 MacBook Pro 4,1; 17" 2.5GHz Core2Duo and I upgraded the hard drive to a Kingston SV100S2 128GB SSD drive.


It worked perfectly for the first 4 months after purchase but 3 weeks ago the problem started when I tried to start my MBP and the grey Apple logo appeared with a kind of progress bar underneath it and then it would just power off (SMC and PRAM reset didn't help). The disk utility showed an "invalid node structure" problem which it wasn't able to fix and later the disk would be unreadable. Since the first time, this has recurred about 6 times. Each time I had to format the drive, install Mac OS X 10.6.3 again from either original DVD or it's image on hard drive (which is much faster), and transfer files from a Time Machine backup.


The drive would subsequently fail again after a couple of days each time. I have discovered that Kingston has released and official URGENT firmware upgrade, which I have installed after the 3rd failure, but it apparently didn't help. Also disabling hibernation and sudden motion sensor had nothing to do with it. Last time it failed (today), I was installing some updates and it failed after I was restarting, but I don't think it has anything to do with it either.


I am taking the drive back next morning to the retailer, where I bought it cheaply as a business owner, and I will ask them for a replacement, however I am still not sure if it could be my mac causing this chaos with the drive or the SATA cable being faulty.


I would welcome and be thankful for any constructive thoughts. Right now I had to replace the drive with the original one and everything is literarily at least 5 times slower and takes as much longer time to load, what is really bothering me. Thanks again.


Marek (Slovakia/UK)

MacBook Pro 17" 2.5GHz Penryn, Mac OS X (10.5.3)

Posted on Apr 17, 2011 2:47 PM

Reply
69 replies

Mar 21, 2012 7:07 AM in response to elioc9

Just curious, the retailer that gave your money back, was it Media Market? This is where I bought mine.


Your observation about power consumption might be key. I have two of the v100's in two mini's. One is a server, always on. The other mini (which died) was regularly put asleep or powered down.


I have since bought a 128Gb Verbatim unit for the client-mini.


Cumprimentos.

Mar 21, 2012 7:28 AM in response to UserNameX

nope, was a online shop chipsite.pt. they sent it to the factory, then retailer said the ssd was discontinued and the manufacturer gave order to refund me. lucky me hehe.

on windows this SSD work pretty well, so the problem can only be the osx


EDIT: i forgot to say, for my corsair sdd i used this tweaks . try all this things and then say if they solve the problem 🙂


Message was edited by: elioc9

Mar 21, 2012 7:27 AM in response to UserNameX

You will just encounter the problem if you reboot/restart your mac, it will happen in its loading phase.


In other words, if you never reboot your mac you will never have this problem.


This is what I conclued from my 2 months of constantly formats.


I also figure it out that on windows, SSD just works fine, and I have 2 friends with apple original SSD, with more or less that 1 year of usage and so far so good, no problems with them.


Conclusions... SSD is not from Apple, you will have nightmares...

Mar 21, 2012 7:38 AM in response to NsJenjia

I had the same problem spent 2 months of constantly doing formats, every week.


Your problem was with OS X Lion? - I'll recommend you try what I did, In my case the problem seems to be the "Recovery Partion" once you install Lion its created-automatic, so what i did was:


1- Download http://www.bombich.com/ Carbon Copy Cloner

2- Clone your old HD ::> To :::> New SSD

3- That's it.


There will be no "recovery partition" but it's useless anyway if you have the OS X Lion setup on a USB drive.

Let me know how it goes.


Cheers

Mar 22, 2012 3:25 AM in response to NsJenjia

re: formated the SSD entirely (using another MAC, if you use the same MAC the recovery will not be deleted)


If you boot using Lion's Command-R option, then the recovery partition is in use and hence you cannot reformat the entire SSD. Need to boot from USB or a DVD in order to enable Disk Utility the possibility of reformatting the complete SSD. So for reformatting purposes, there's no need to pull the disk and put it in another mac.

Mar 31, 2012 4:01 PM in response to himynameismarek

Same issue here. Maybe this could help...


SV100S2 - Solid-State Drive SSDNow V100 Firmware update


Description:

We have discovered a technical issue with our SSDNow V100 which could result in drive failure. While we have observed this issue in only a small percentage of drives, Kingston strongly recommends that a firmware update be applied to all V100 drives to prevent possible failure.

Apr 21, 2012 6:52 AM in response to himynameismarek

Exact same problem as original poster


2007 Macbook Pro 15


SSD (256)


KINGSTON SV100S2256G:


Capacity: 256.06 GB (256,060,514,304 bytes)

Model: KINGSTON SV100S2256G

Revision: D110225a


(so mine has the rev)


Worked fine for about 4 months then problem started.


Mine works ok UNLESS I shutdown completely and dont boot it for 6-12hrs


The the inode problem happens (and can repair same as rest of you)


So the big question is drive or Mac/OS ?


***** - I really like this drive - fast and no noise - but the lack of reliability is a stopper


may go back to conventional drive If I cant get resolution soon


Ive email Kingston tech support - will report results


(btw - i had the 'hack' to allow TRIM in Snow - worked fine - once I got the problem i disabled it - but no change)

(** found people with same issue on another forum and they are seeing the same thing - even without the trim hack, with much newer macs than mine and with Lion that supports trim out of the box)

Jun 10, 2012 3:54 PM in response to cighh

Ok. I got tired of fighting with this SSD, RMAed it and received Kingston SNVP325-S2/128GB, it's a V+ series. Works with out problem for 2 days now, goes to sleep, to hybernate mode etc without any problem and errors. Checked SSD multiple times. I'll see how long this one will last. So if you still haveyour SSD SV100S2 under warranty - just RMA it and get another model. I think this is a best way to resolve this issue.

I also would like to mention a couple of things:

- RMA process was painless and fast (Kingston used Fedex overnight to ship it to me) and my RMA was 2 days under review after Kingston received my ssd;

- kingston mailed me recertified ssd (but looks like new and hopefully will work too).

- tested the speed of new SSD: writing 109MB/s, reading 130 MB/s. I did not test my old Kingston which I retutned, but my SSD OCZ Vertex 2 shows 230 MB/s and 250 MB/s resepectivelly (under ms windows). MBP 2007 artificially use sata 1.5, so it may affect the speed. Anyway this kingston ssd is faster than original hdd.

Kingston ssd revived my MBP 2007 - so it is good enough for money.

Jun 10, 2012 4:31 PM in response to artemych

I just quited this bulls***t, spoke with my SSD seller and he send it back to kingstom, them made a refund, and will stick with my old HHD...now I living my life with my mac slower, but better.


Point of interest of this post is...


In my searchs over the internet I found somewhere that the problem was with the cable that connect the Mac with the SSD, it is for SATA2, and actual SSD that you buy outside Apple are SATA3. And that will cause the problems later or sooner.


I can't confirm this... but is the farest I made in my extend research over this topic.

Jun 11, 2012 1:05 AM in response to NsJenjia

It's been 3 months with the Corsair and I noticed a couple things. First 2 days I didn't have TRIM enabled using the TRIM Enabler 2.1 for Lion and the system started getting a little bit slower and had som lags. After I enabled TRIM it just got significantly faster and even started up 15 seconds faster. Few days ago after the 10.7.4 update I got the wheel of fortune at the login screen so I knew something was up. Checked the TRIM enabler and it was off, so I switched it back on, restarted (it said it couldn't enable right away) and it's fine now. TRIM definitely makes it run faster and probably extends the life span of the drive.


The cause of this problem still seems to be unknown and impossible to specify. Could be brand/chip specific, caused by voltage/power regulation, incompatible mac hardware (cable or I/O), or fast wear due to non-functioning TRIM.


Anyway, if this drive goes then I'm done with SSDs as well.

Jun 11, 2012 6:17 AM in response to himynameismarek

Marek:


Thanks for the tip of TRIM enabler. Have downloaded it from www.groths.org and will test it.


I am using one 64 GB Kensington, and one 128GB Verbatim SSD. My "solution" six-months-and-counting with two mac mini's has been to disable sleep and hibernate. This costs more energy -- being always on -- but the boxes are cooler with SSD's inside. Now the power transformer bricks are the main source of waste heat/energy.

SSD Invalid node structure on MBP 4,1

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple ID.