Pros and cons so far
So far there are a couple of things I like about this new format, with — hopefully — more to come as I become more used to it.
- I really like having the reply box show up inside the thread to which I'm replying. It's easier to refresh my memory about what I'm saying if I'm interrupted in the middle.
- I'm finding it easy to read the various posts. I have the HD screen on my MBP, so the type on the old forum was quite small. This is better for me, though I suspect it's not for a lot of people.
The major part of this new community idea that I am having trouble with, like so many others, is the navigation. I've gone through setting up my view, but it just doesn't feel as user-friendly and intuitive as navigation in the old forum did.
Things I think need to be brought back:
- name of the OP in the listings
- name of the last person to respond
- location of the poster (the answer to an iPhone question coming from the UK, for example, would be different from that of one coming from the US)
- the date the poster joined the forum/community
And, yes, I know I can get the last two bits of information from the profile page. But why do I want to navigate away from the question, find the information, and then navigate back to the question? A quick glance at the information on the question page should be all that is necessary.