Apple Event: May 7th at 7 am PT

Looks like no one’s replied in a while. To start the conversation again, simply ask a new question.

I Broke My iPad 2

User uploaded file


Yup. A $500 magic media/business/gaming/entertainment plaything ... and I dropped it right on its corner onto the cold, hard concrete of Hoboken Terminal.


The impact shattered the glass, dented the corner and made me vomit on my shoes.


The iPad still worked perfectly but it's beautiful face was scarred beyond repair. Its Joker-smile of a crack mocked my inability to hold onto so precious an item. We use the iPad to prepare Keynote presentations for work, read stories to the kids, play games and watch TV. All of those functions would not be a problem even with the cracked glass, except for reading to the kids. Because picking glass out their hands after a bedtime story doesn't sound like too much fun.


After pulling myself together enough to move on, I began researching repair options. I had not purchased the AppleCare warranty but even if I had, it doesn't cover accidental drops. So I was out of luck with Apple. There were a few places that would be able to repair the glass and the digitizer but the costs would range from $150.00 to $350.00. I might as well buy a new iPad 2.


I decided to ask Apple what the best options were. Maybe they would let me mail it back to them, pay a repair fee and then have it shipped back in 2-3 weeks time. That would have been acceptable except that I had a presentation to deliver at work in TWO days. I figured I could inquire, get the info, do the presentation and then ship off the iPad ... if that was even an option. I had to try.


So I made an appointment at the Genius Bar at the Apple Store in Menlo Park Mall for that evening. With my tail tucked between my legs, I walked up to the Bar and showed them what happened. The Genius, Ray B., took a look and said "Wow, right on the corner huh?". I meekly answered yes and said "I know there isn't much you can do, but we use this for a lot of stuff and I have a presentation to do on Friday so I just want to know what Apple's recommendations are for repair."


Ray said there are options and began to take down my info. He plugged in the serial number of my iPad into his iPhone, pulled up the purchase date and said, "You ordered this on Day One and have had it less than a month." Again, meekly I answered yes as if being admonished for my irresponsibility. Ray told me to hang on while he went to the back to get some more info. As Ray left, I could only stare at my broken, but still functional iPad. I hoped that the pricing for repair options was not going to be terrible.


When Ray came back, I braced for the numbers and he said ..


"Now, you know drops aren't covered by the warranty right?"


*gulp*


"Yeah, I just want to get the best, Apple-recommended options for fixing it."


"Unfortunately, we can't just repair the glass on this because it's one whole unit. We'd have to take it all apart and start over to make sure it's done right."


*double gulp*


"OK"


"So listen, you've had it for less than a month. We want you to enjoy the experience so this will be a one time exception but I'm just going to replace it with a brand new one. Cool?"


*blank stare*


At this point, Ray was smiling at me but I wasn't sure if it was a mocking, late April Fool's, you're-an-idiot smile.


*blank stare*


"What? Really? You can do that?"


"Sure. Like I said it's a one time thing but this will help us make the products better and you clearly use it so we want you to keep using it happily."


"You'll replace this? With a new one? When?"


"Right now. I'll just fill out the paperwork, you sign it, give me this one and walk out with the new one."


It took every ounce of restraint for me to not hug Ray B. right there.


So just like that, I bought, broke and got a brand new iPad 2 all in one month. Now I fully realize how fortunate I was. Ray B. could've been having a bad day and decided that I was SOL. But all of this is a testament to how Apple puts the customers first.


Thanks Apple! Thanks Ray B.! YOU ROCK!

iPad 2, iOS 4.3.1

Posted on Apr 18, 2011 6:02 AM

Reply
23 replies

Jul 12, 2011 12:49 PM in response to jeofv

im in tears when i read this, cause i got a dent in one of my pad's corner but the machine worked just as great as it did before i accidentally dropped it on the floor. one month later the machine wouldnt charge, gets a 'u should charge' sign on the screen but it doesnt connect. The man in the shop said it couldnt be fixed because of the dent so im here with no iPad cause i cant afford to buy a new one/repair..... this is upsetting, cause this shows how big the differences are from store to store 😟 Im so glad u and all u other guys got new ones but at the same time it kinda hurts too.....

Jul 17, 2011 11:02 AM in response to Ferrr

wow, is norway that horrible at helping their customers compared to other countries???? Its imbarassing... I complained and they are going to look at it again, so im waiting for the answer now. SO glad i didnt buy any of the stuff i planned on yet, like keyboard, cardreader and all kinds of goodies. Il never use apple again if this comes down to being treated like **** by some of the workers when lots and lots of people get new products when they break theirs...

Dec 4, 2011 9:02 PM in response to jeofv

These stories just upset me. For the past three years I have been buying everything Apple. I replaced two PC's with two iMacs and got a Mac Mini for the kids. I went WiFi with 3 Airport Extreme Routers set up to extened network throughout my pre-Ethernet-wiring home. I bought Apple TV1 and Apple TV2. I got an iPod touch 2g, and 2 x iPhone 3GS for me and my wife. I bought the first iPad, sold it one year later and bought the iPad 2. Recently we upgraded to iPhone 4S for both me and my wife. Being the tech wizard in the family I have also recommended Apple products to family members and to many friends at church. I even call AppleCare support to point out fixes to problems I find with Mac OSX when they can't solve it and I track down the solution so they can share that with others. Yet, I can say that unless my Apple product was under warranty I have never been offered any sort of free repair or replacement.


My mother in law dropped her out-of-warranty iPhone 3G in water and got a new one for free, but when my 3GS had the GPS give out they wanted $150 to replace the 22-month old phone. Recently my iPad 2 slipped out of my hand while in its case and the corner is now dented and slightly sharp with the corner glass raised just enough to let dust in under the glass. I went to the genius bar to find out my repair options and learned it would cost $419 (half the price of my iPad 2) for Apple to take my old one and replace it. Even though Apple would simply refurb my iPad 2 and sell it for $780 on their online store.


So sure it's wonderful that some of you folks get special treatment, but don't tout Apple's customer service as if this is always the case. This clearly an exception and it's one that very few get - even some of Apple's best customers like myself don't get this kind of special treatment. Folks should not read these stories and expect this kind of treatment. Look to AppleCare+ or SquareTrade warranties if you expect this kind of service.

Dec 12, 2011 2:51 PM in response to BC2010

As an update to this I want to share something. First off, Apple just dropped their refurbished iPad 2 pricing by $50 per model. Secondly, Apple replaces an iPhone 4S (any model) for $200 with trade-in to refurbish. I've also seen Apple fix the iPhone 4/4S glass for $30 for a customer behind me in line at the genius bar (which is more than reasonable). I brought this to Apple's attention by calling AppleCare support and talking to a supervisor. My basic question was "why was Apple profiting off the misfortune of their customers when they break something"? Considering they get $420 from the trade-in of a top-model iPad 2 which they refurbish and then sell for $780 (now $730 after price drop) that totalled $1200 for the iPad 2 replacement. Apple of course makes a huge profit on the original $830 price tag on the top-model iPad 2, so at $1200 they are definitely covering their refurbish costs and making a hefty profit (mine required a part that retails at $120, so cost is probably around $60 plus labor).


It seems the iPhone model of $200 replacements is meant to be fair, while the iPad model is meant to be exorbitant. The suprvisor agreed with me and created a case number that would be forwarded to the right people at Apple and reviewed.


On the phone call I explicitly pointed out that I felt making exceptions was not the right policy and that what customers simply wanted was a fair repair/replacement price since Apple cannot be responsible for folks dropping their stuff and breaking it. Those who complain the most should not get special treatment. I told him that $200 seemed to be a fair replacement price given what they do for iPhone and since iPhone 4S costs as much as an iPad 2 off-contract. The supervisor then said he would try to make things right by replacing my iPad 2. I said "for $200?" and he responded "at no cost to you". This floored me. I did not deserve a free replacement. I broke the device, not Apple. But the supervisor said it was the only thing in his power to do and he wanted to make things right. I was not going to turn down a free replacement. But my real hope is that going forward we have some decent repair/replace options for iPads just like we do for iPhones. I'm hoping some things I said make sense to those that create the repair/replace policy. I am hoping this because I plan to buy more iPads in the years to come and I imagine I may drop one of them as well.


I also stand by the statement that those who want free/cheap replacements for accidental damage should look into AppleCare+ (for iPhone) and SquareTrade for everything else. My case is by no means the norm, but I am hoping that in the future Apple provides repair terms for iPad that are more reasonable so up-front warranties or talking to supervisors are not the only option.


I appreciate what Apple did to make things right in this case. I hope they make things right in the long term for everybody.

May 9, 2012 7:08 AM in response to jeofv

My expirience at Menlo Park Apple store - with my iPad(3rd Gen)


Location: Menlo Park Apple Store, New Jersey


Exprience Date: May 8th, 2012


Issue Desc:

Ordered my iPad (3rd Gen) thru apple.com on March 10th, received on March 16th (delighted !).

But on May 7th, noticed a gap near the front camera area between the glass and plastic/ rubber casing


How it went !


Set up appointment with genius bar at 8:45 pm on 5/8.

Walked in to the store at 8:40 pm & checked in .


Waiting anxiously for next steps...!..a bit worried too 😉


After 10 minutes, the apple genius bar rep. took a brief look the issue - quickly acknowledged the issue and advised to replace it with a brand new device....

At that point, I was clearly appreciative of Apple's commitment for customer satisfaction !!.

How often do you expeirence such a commited support ?!...nice hah ?!


My replacement device did NOT come in the magic box packaging, it was just a brown box - but the genius bar rep. assured me that it was a brand new iPad ( I take her word for it).


She then set up my Apple account on the replaced device, transferred my AT&T LTE account to the new iPad

Lastly, she wiped the data/ emails , etc on the old devivce....(apparently it a apple policy to wipe out all retiurned devices...sure , makes sense).


BTW, the new replaced iPad device Serial # starts with DY.....



Thank you.

I Broke My iPad 2

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple ID.