iChat vs. Yahoo Messenger

I have been using Yahoo Messenger to Video chat with a friend on a PC. The picture quality is much better than AIM, and I don't care about the lack of audio.

I gave my friend my old Powerbook Ti/1.0 and got a new HD model so we are trying out iChat AV now. I am past all of the router issues, and we are able to use iChat pretty well for audio and video.

My question is that the video in Yahoo is much clearer (when using Yahoo's Super mode), but the frame rate is pretty low (1-2 fps?). iChat has a much better frame rate, but the resolution is WAY lower.

For me, the video quality of Yahoo outweighs the high frame rate of iChat.

Is there any way to trade off some of the high frame rate in iChat for a higher resolution picture? The difference is VERY dramatic...

I really want to use iChat, but I find myself being drawn to Yahoo for the pristine picture...

Everyone else I read about says Yahoo is terrible, and I wonder if they don't have "super mode" working (which take a router config to pass through port 5100/tcp). Maybe they can't get past the lack of audio, but for me, the pictures is more important.

Anyone have comments or suggestions?

Powerbook G4 17HD, Mac OS X (10.4.3)

Posted on Jan 5, 2006 5:24 PM

Reply
2 replies

Jan 6, 2006 12:49 PM in response to aross99

Hi Aross99,

The more an application puts into sending a good picure the slower the frame rate will be. A very good picture takes the same amount of data as several lesser quality ones.

Faster frame rates are smoother.

Judgement is personal of speed over quality.

I personally like smoothness of video.

The quality of video will depend on how fast your processor is and what else it is doing.

If you adjust the Yahoo! framerate/quality the picture is probably the same for the same frame rate.

Ralph

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

iChat vs. Yahoo Messenger

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.