Best Buy made good
On May 4, my wife and I bought iPhone 4s at Apple Store – mine black, hers white. Then had Best Buy install Zagg Invisible Shields on front of both phones. My wife later noticed her phone screen didn’t turn off during calls (mine worked fine). Found four discussions of the issue (listed below), with Zagg covering the white proximity sensor evidently being the problem.
Went to an iPhone class at the Apple Store, and they confirmed that the problem was the shield blocking the proximity sensor. (BTW, also found out that none of the Apple Store employees used a screen cover because the quality of the iPhone 4 glass is so high.)
Then returned to Best Buy. Employee removed Zagg and proximity sensor began working. No problem in returning the Zagg Invisible Shield, and getting our money back for both the product and Best Buy’s installation. (Interestingly, the employee also had a white iPhone without a screen cover.)
IMPORTANT:Best Buy employee said cutting a hole for the proximity sensor would void the Zagg warranty.
Here are the discussion sites:
Apple Support Discussions – “Proximity Sensor not working on White iPhone 4”
https://discussions.apple.com/thread/3031122?answerId=15224209022#15224209022
MacRumors Forums (1) – “White iPhone 4 w/ Zagg - Proximity not working”
http://forums.macrumors.com/showthread.php?t=1146387
MacRumors Forums (2) – “iPhone 4 Proximity sensor, Black vs. White”
http://forums.macrumors.com/showthread.php?t=1146402
The iPhoneAddict – “Proximity sensor issues with white iPhone 4”
http://www.theiphoneaddict.com/problems-2/proximity-sensor-issues-with-white-iph one-4/#comment-206072330