With Half-Sized Frame and SP/LP error, am I getting lower quality?

Seven years ago, I recorded some videos with my Canon ZR miniDV camcorder. I want to preserve the quality of these videos by archiving them on my Mac. The read head on this camcorder is broken. So, I'm borrowing my brother's Sony Digital Handycam DCR-PC110 NTSC to play these miniDV video tapes.


When I use iMovie 6 to import, I get this message:


"The camera is sending half-sized frames, which iMovie can’t accept. Check your camera’s record mode (this is the setting that affects recording quality, which determines the total recording time on a tape). The mode must be set to “SP” or “LP.” If that doesn't help, try removing all the cables and batteries from the camera, wait a minute, replace them, and then reset the date, time, and record mode."


The recording mode is already set to "SP". However, I still cannot import. Every time I try to play the video, it shows a fraction of a second of the video and then it stops. If I disconnect the camera from the Mac, I can play the video without a problem. It seems that iMovie 6 will not allow me to play this video.


Does anybody know what the problem is?


With my brother's miniDV tapes, I don't get this problem on his Sony Digital Handycam.


From some research, I read that it might have something to do with playing a PAL recording instead of NTSC. However, my cameras are NTSC. I've never (consciously or remember to) use PAL. iMovie 6 is set to 29.97 bps frame rate, which is supposedly NTSC.

I tried the suggestion from this posting:

https://discussions.apple.com/thread/379223

Which is:

- I disconnected the camera from the Mac.

- Started up iMovie 6.

- Started playing my miniDV tape.

- Connected the firewire from the camera to the Mac


Now, I can play and import the miniDV video on iMovie 6. However, I'm curious as to whether iMovie is inputting NTSC and saving into PAL, or vice versa. Therefore, I'm concerned about the possibility of losing quality. Would anybody know if I will be losing quality?

MacBook Pro, Mac OS X (10.6.7)

Posted on May 3, 2011 12:13 PM

Reply
19 replies

May 5, 2011 9:10 AM in response to Tom Wolsky

My main objective is to preserve quality when importing. If in the future, I want to share the video, I assume that I can simply send the .DV files. If I want to edit the clips into a movie, by using iMovie, then are you saying that I should do this with iMovie 6 HD, and not iMovie 11? What if I want to create a movie from the clips and share it on Youtube? Does it matter if I use iMovie 6 or 11?

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

With Half-Sized Frame and SP/LP error, am I getting lower quality?

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.