The iguy cover was ok when my kids were very young. Although the first iguys I bought fitted tightly which was good. Later I bought some more which were too loose (same product but the batch must have been faulty). I sent them back but got one replacement that was too big which I have thrown in the spare room. The other was not too bad but still a bit loose (you don't want the ipad to fall out of the case or to be too easy to pull out of the case if little hands decide to have a go). My original iguys have cracks in the corners of the cases from having dropped on the floor and the ipads were damaged too. Yes the sponge rubber can eventuall crack over time! There is no protective cover for the screen with the iguy. Looking at the other case you recommended it looks like no screen protection. Using the iguy with 2 older children under 7 (one with quite severe autism) I have seen the ipad dropped on the tiles (of course the corner hits first sometimes. I wouldn't recommend these covers for older children, only for littlies around 3-5 and even then I'd be watching carefully with the 5 year olds or small children who are rough. They don't understand how much the ipads are to replace (usually $270 under applecare if they say the unit has been damaged). It's rough for an autistic child to be without an ipad once they have become used to it. My youngest child falls asleep with his ipad and his ball (he loves musical playlists from youtube). I highly recommend ipads for children with autism and for children who are normal. The benefits in learning, music and art are incredible and children seem to master the ipads faster than adults do. It also empowers children to be able to select and play their own choices from a range of apps you have provided them. I have apps for the kids that include music, jigsaw puzzles, construction and train track and putting your train on it ... and watching it go, farmyard fun (place animals on the farm), read along books, songs including alphabet songs, painting apps (touch and paint), matching games, video playlists, maths and english.. plus lots more.