I just noticed that Apple, on its web pages introducing and promoting and describing Lion in great detail, shows the traditional Mac desktop - with Finder windows and so forth - in exactly one screenshot, and that's the one at the very bottom of the page that's illustrating Lion Server, not the personal Lion with whose look and feel all of us here are so frustrated. (And it's easy in this screenshot to overlook the grayed out icons we dislike so much.)
I take this as simply more evidence that the company is urging, coercing, persuading, nudging and generally pushing us away from the old desktop and into the new realm of an iPod-inspired interface. Its icons, you'll notice, are still all very bright and large and showing in easy-to-distinguish designs and colors.
If this really is Apple's intention, to move us along and away from the past, then I doubt very much that the firm will listen to any calls for a return to the old way(s). Let's not forget that this company prides itself on its GUI and any decision to abandon or diminish the old one as they have must have been done with great intention. It was not an idle whim or miscalculation. No doubt whole committees spent time on this, and Mr. Jobs, too.
Even if they're not trumpeting this change, it's clearly something strategic and something they are unlikely to retreat from. There's probably more to come, too. We're seeing only the first steps into a brave new world.
None of which is to say I am happy with the change or see much reason behind it. I am not using a laptop with gestures - I am writing, mostly, on a tower machine with traditional keyboard and mouse. I like to see "inside" my computer, to know how its files are organized and related, etc. I don't want to be shut out or discouraged from using this traditional view. It's what I know.