13 Replies Latest reply: Aug 4, 2011 10:35 AM by Nately
VegasWineGuy Level 1 Level 1 (0 points)

I have my files on my idisk and when I try to close the new updated file, I get a message that the document is on a volume that does not support permanent version storage...

  • zachs Level 2 Level 2 (155 points)

    Versions does not work with files stored on iDisk. The app has to support it as well.

     

    Sorry, that's incorrect.

     

    Message was edited by: zachs

  • Pondini Level 8 Level 8 (38,720 points)

    I think it is correct.

     

    In testing, it would not work on network drives.

     

    The Duplicate option will probably work.

  • VegasWineGuy Level 1 Level 1 (0 points)

    Any idea if it will work in iCloud?

  • xprsnism Level 1 Level 1 (0 points)

    I can confirm that versioning doesn't work over the network here as noted on

    https://discussions.apple.com/thread/3192600?start=0&tstart=0.

  • Graham Perrin Level 2 Level 2 (255 points)

    Please: has anyone in this topic tested with AFP service provided by Lion Server?

     

    Suggesting incompatibility with networked environments may be a little premature

     

    For additional information, please:

     

    • see my post and others in a recent topic, Where exactly are old versions of files stored on the harddisk?
    • expect Apple to publish relevant details, maybe aimed at developers, in due course.
  • coocooforcocoapuffs Level 3 Level 3 (845 points)

    Versioning does not work at all, anywhere, if the file is moved from it's original saved location. Many of us have posted this here in this forum. I think we will have to wait for a fix from apple on this one.

  • Graham Perrin Level 2 Level 2 (255 points)

    Moving — good catch. The simplest thiings are often overlooked.

     

    Without moving, a few minutes ago I tested 11A511 with AFP service provided by Mac OS X Server 10.6.8. First impressions are that it's problem free:

     

    • used Finder to copy a .png screenshot from my local desktop to somewhere on the remote volume
    • opened the copy in Preview, edited, command-q quit from Preview
    • disconnected from the server, reconnected
    • reopened the file
    • browsed versions — versions present.

     

    Please, do you have a link to any of the other topics?

     

    Thanks

  • Pondini Level 8 Level 8 (38,720 points)

    Graham Perrin wrote:

     

    Moving — good catch. The simplest thiings are often overlooked.

     

    Without moving, a few minutes ago I tested 11A511 with AFP service provided by Mac OS X Server 10.6.8. First impressions are that it's problem free:

     

    • used Finder to copy a .png screenshot from my local desktop to somewhere on the remote volume
    • opened the copy in Preview, edited, command-q quit from Preview
    • disconnected from the server, reconnected
    • reopened the file
    • browsed versions — versions present.

     

    That will work if the remote volume supports it.   And the Versions info is on that volume, in a /.DocumentRevisions-V100 folder, not your OSX drive.  If you move it elsewhere, all you'll get is the current version.

  • Graham Perrin Level 2 Level 2 (255 points)

    Pondini wrote:

    … the Versions info is on that volume, in a /.DocumentRevisions-V100 folder, not your OSX drive. …

     

    In my most recent test with the same AFP server, the versions for a remote .png screenshot:

     

     

    reunion:~ centrimadmin$ ls -ld  /.DocumentRevisions-V100
    ls: /.DocumentRevisions-V100: No such file or directory
    

     

    Locally there might be some related data at

    /.DocumentRevisions-V100

    but in this case, the versions of the remote file are local, and not limited to the root user. See for example screenshot 001 at http://www.wuala.com/grahamperrin/public/2011/07/25/e/?mode=gallery demonstrating the local versions of the remote file, opened after disconnecting from the file server.

     

    Readers, whilst there are unknowns please do not tinker unnecessarily with the contents of your ~/Library

     

    In most topics Apple Support Communities is failing horribly for me so I can't promise to post all relevant details in the Apple area. If you like, follow my microblog

     

    I await additional publications from Apple.

  • Pondini Level 8 Level 8 (38,720 points)

    That's not what I'm seeing; if I edit a file on another volume, a /.DocumentRevisions-V100 folder is created on it.

     

    Why would that happen if that's not where the "pieces" are saved?

     

    If I edit a file on a remote volume that doesn't support Versions, I get various error messages, either when trying to make a new version, or when trying to close the document.

  • Graham Perrin Level 2 Level 2 (255 points)

    With regret I'm stepping away from most Apple Support Discussions until the worst of the Apple Support Discussions bugs are fixed. More often than not, the service sends me to the wrong page. It's stupendously difficult to work with such badly broken navigation. Au revoir …

  • Graham Perrin Level 2 Level 2 (255 points)

    Folks, Pondini in particular:

     

    I'm acutely aware that I disappeared from a few topics without offering any hint of where I might go. My apologies.

     

    From now on I'll be present — answering questions, chatting et cetera — in Ask Different and Ask Different Chat (much more than in Apple Support Communities — explanation).

  • Nately Level 1 Level 1 (145 points)

    Graham Perrin wrote:

     

    Moving — good catch. The simplest thiings are often overlooked.

     

    Without moving, a few minutes ago I tested 11A511 with AFP service provided by Mac OS X Server 10.6.8. First impressions are that it's problem free:

     

    • used Finder to copy a .png screenshot from my local desktop to somewhere on the remote volume
    • opened the copy in Preview, edited, command-q quit from Preview
    • disconnected from the server, reconnected
    • reopened the file
    • browsed versions — versions present.

     

    Please, do you have a link to any of the other topics?

     

    Thanks

    So it works if you quit the program. It does not work for me when I close the file window.

     

    This makes me wonder whether the Restore feature in Lion is tied in with versions. i.e. Your workflow is not accessing the versions stored for the file, but simply the restore point for the application at the time of quit, which may happen to include the versions.