Dear Neville,
Thanks for your reply. In this thread we are discussing a bug in which the sensible points you make in your post appear to break down. The iLife Apps on my machine (a current-generation MBA) were pre-installed. But on one hand they seem to be treated as though they were purchased through the App store -- for instance, updates are not available through Software Update, and trying to install the iPhoto update after downloading if from the software update website gives an error:
"The version of iPhoto installed on this Mac must be updated through the Mac App Store. Check the Mac App Store to see if an update is available."
And on the other hand, since the Apps were not actually purchased through my Apple account, it is not possible to update them through the App Store either.
A few tricks have been posted in this thread but they do not appear to work universally -- at least none of them work for me. And, whereas the App Store customer support apparently used to hand out redemption codes so that people with this problem could delete and re-install the Apps, they seem to be refusing to do this now. At least that was the result of a long back-and-forth I had with customer support today, where they specifically refused to give out a redemption code and stated the following:
"Apple is currently working toward a resolution for the issue you have reported. You will receive an email after the matter has been investigated and further information is available."
This is totally unacceptable -- the above statement could mean days, weeks, or months, and in the meantime the new iPhoto/iOS 5 features are unavailable to me. I have no real confidence that I'm going to get an email at some future unspecified time. And redemption codes to fix the problem and end the frustration would cost Apple nothing.
This is a huge waste of time and I am ******.