Apple Event: May 7th at 7 am PT

Looks like no one’s replied in a while. To start the conversation again, simply ask a new question.

Lion's Address Book - A WARNING

for those upgrading to the latest version of osx ("lion"), a word of warning. prepare to groan over some annoying changes to ical. but when you launch the new address book, be careful. your first impulse, like mine, may be to jump out the nearest window.


apple's later rev to address book is a TOTAL DISASTER. and just to be clear: the problem is not the ugly "leather" cover (but make no mistake: it is ugly) or the misguided and juvenile attempt to mimic a real-world object (for the sake, one assumes, of simplicity and ease of use). the problem is that the "updated" functionality of the address book *****. it is both harder to use and less useful than its predecessor.


being able to see groups, people, and their data at the same time is essential to easily modify and browse the address book. now not only do i have a more difficult click-path to navigate my contacts, but i have to hold in memory (my memory) the context of what i am looking at.


the old address book, while not perfect by any means, helped me organize and use my contacts. the new address books makes it significantly more difficult. in this age of social networking where people and connections are fundamental to how we work and play on the web, is this really the best apple could do? TOTAL FAIL, APPLE.

iMac / iBook / iPhone, Mac OS X (10.5.2)

Posted on Jul 31, 2011 11:30 AM

Reply
52 replies

Feb 10, 2012 12:02 PM in response to markmal

This is horrible - HORRIBLE. Today I tried to create first a Group, then a Smart Group. I felt like I'd been dropped head-first into WindowsWorld. It is THAT BAD. Did they subcontract this application to the brains at Microsoft?


I'm not even going to try any longer to figure out how to use this; I'll go download some other program.


I've never been about to figure out why AB was a separate application from Mail, anyway. Their functions are so interdependent, why isn't one a subset of the other? But that's a philosophical argument, and a flaw I could live with. This "improvement"? No way. My time is too valuable to spend compensating for Apple's mistakes.


I did find online advice that, by adding DeBug to the AB Menu, I could find and select Classic View. Not any more, apparently. What a drag.

Jul 3, 2012 7:18 PM in response to markmal

Just upgraded to Lion and not impressed at all. It's like Vista for Windows. Why try to make everything like iPad?

Totally annoyed with the Address Book! Old Address Book is, actually was the heart of my company and now after the upgrade to Lion I'm ******!

Why in the world Apple you are doing this? Why needs you stupid iPad like solutions for real world business? Bloody toy company, I am very angry.

Instead of doing business I'm forced now to go and find good alternative to Address Book somewhere else, which takes my time off the real world problems.

You took away Mobile Me product which was already good for me and replaced it with totally useless iCloud and iStupiPads like apps

Fck you Apple! Bring back 3 panels address book please or I am mowing to Windows!

Jul 4, 2012 4:30 AM in response to CGEA

Apple is slowly but surely moving out of application software and focusing just on the IOS operating system and a few areas it views as essential to its growth: iphoto/aperture is an example because cameras and photo software are essential to iPhone growth. It is quietly ditching address book, ical, has already ditched iweb, has made a terrible mess of final cut pro. These apps have worsened with latest releases of IOS and are never updated between IOS releases, even for known bugs. The latest Lion version of address book is simply appalling and Apple should be ashamed of itself for even considering releasing such a piece of junk. Yuk.

You are right in saying you'll have to go find an alternative via third parties - and pay for something you always had as part of Apple's offering. It is easier to understand now why IOS upgrades are cheaper and cheaper.

Apple makes a lot more money from third party apps than from its own. So the strategy is to make its own clearly unpalatable creating room for others to fill. And take a 30% cut having done nothing other than posting it on the App Store. Brilliant strategy we end up paying for.

But while in the Calendar space there are some excellent alternatives, these are sorely missing in the contacts area. There is absolutely nothing worth having in contacts management. I believe I've tried everything under the sun in that space and am shocked by the lack of well designed apps. The latest fad for a few weeks - Cobook - is only a gadgety useless addition that in no way replaces or improves on the missing funtionalities of the SL contacts app.

Expect to pay more and more in future for basic app substitutes on your Apple platform.

Any suggestion welcome.


BTW Mattias Holm of Openorbit is developing an app that mimics the old SL address book app we are all missing. The first release was very disappointing and the update is taking ages to come but apparently is about to be released at long last (from last November). Lets hope he is succesfull, we wish him the best.

Jul 4, 2012 4:34 AM in response to enricus28

Apple has traditionally supported 3rd party developers. I was quite amazed when, early in the 2000’s, Apple began to offer their own apps in areas formerly belongind to others: Safari (web browsing, but it is udnerstandable why), iwork (replacing Claris, initially an independent company, later taken over by Apple), then the whole series of apps like iCal, Mail.app etc. etc. to say nothing of their pro apps.

I would not be surprised if Apple reconsidered their policy here, and gradually concentrate on some areas, and also gradually abandoning some of their apps, even if this seems ilogical: iCal, Mail, Safari, iBooks (perhaps to be a part of iWork?) belong to current use, the same is valid for iPhoto or iTunes.

I am not enthusiastic about Address Book or iCal, perhaps should consider some pro apps here, the same about Mail.app

Let us not forget that Apple has had a tremendous jump up over the last years, exactly during a period of crisis, when many companies went down. So I am not so inclined to such a criticism.

Lion's Address Book - A WARNING

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple ID.