Looks like no one’s replied in a while. To start the conversation again, simply ask a new question.

1 OSX Lion Mission Control vs Snow Leopard Expose can't we combine the two (by leaving older Expose options inside) and get Apple back to leaping forward again?

So I am a web/software developer and I am having major beef with OSX Lion's Mission Control. While I think Mission Control and Application Windows are interesting additions to the multi-tasking nature and scheme of the OS, removing the older Expose Spaces and All Windows is a huge mistake. Couldn't Apple have just left all of the old stuff in? Then the system would be complete. As pretty as Mission Control and Application Windows is, the older Snow Leopard Spaces and Expose moved much faster and tamed all of my apps in a very efficient way.

Here is why Mission Control is not as fast as Spaces and Expose:....


1. With Spaces all of the desktops and their connected monitors were consolidated to one monitor in which you can easily see everything going on from a birds eye view. You cloud easily drag open windows between them freely and even swap spaces. This was huge because you could see everything. You could even activate All Windows over Spaces and see everything..Mission Control will group everything but you can't move programs across desktops unless it's the main desktop to the little desktop. Nor can you move windows across monitors. This is frustrating. Also the desktop are split to their respective monitor so I no longer have a birds-eye key-map access.


2. All Windows is so necessary and slick. Mission Control or Application Windows can't quite keep up. If I have a cluttered desktop and hit all windows, I can get any window at any time no matter how buried it is. Application Windows is useful but only applies to the focused application…but what if it's buried? I have to activate mission control first, select one of the windows from the program group, then activate Application Windows to get to that window. Also if there are many windows open for an application, Mission Control cannot replace All Windows because they stack and you can't quite tell which of the windows you want is accessible in that stack.


The bottom line is, put both of them together! Keep the old functionality as an option, because truth be told, the old way of doing things is still considerably faster under heavy work loads. I would use the Snow Leopard expose features more often. There is still room for Application Windows and Mission Control, but even after re-training myself I feel I'm moving at 70% of the multitasking speed that I used to move at before using Snow Leopard Expose. I mean this legitimately, I develop using multiple OS's along with video chat and instead of being a leap forward, Lion is a step backward and that just isn't like apple, everything Apple has done has been leaps and bounds forward. Let's leap forward and not only have all the sweet new features that Lion offers, but combine with the productive features that really moved and maybe just integrate into Lion's style. Bottle that and you have something sweeter than Yoohoo.

Mac OS X (10.7)

Posted on Aug 4, 2011 9:27 PM

Reply
39 replies

Aug 24, 2011 5:23 AM in response to IXXIGolfer

IXXIGolfer wrote:


An application can be assigned to a space - HOWEVER MSSION CONTROL MOVES THE SPACES AROUND making it difficult to predict where the application exists.


This causes an inefficent work flor.


Going back to Snow Leopard for Spaces

OMG - de ja vieux of Vista upgrades to XP

Just go into Mission Control System Preferences and turn that option off.

Sep 23, 2011 8:35 AM in response to airbnboy

just throw "all windows" in there, make the desktops swapabale, and allow me move any window to any desktop on any monitor and we're good...or turn the old stuff back on as an option to combine with the new... or maybe a trick like hovering over a group of windows in MC to expose all of them so the one I want isn't burried

Oct 15, 2011 6:21 AM in response to airbnboy

Absolutely. If we could just have the All Windows in mission control, and alsobe able to click and move applications in the "Desktop thumbnails" then all would be fine. Or maybe even, just keep the all windows feature, like they've kept the "applications window" feature. It can't be that difficult.


For the extremely fast mouse swipe and single click selection experience of "all windows" you now have

to go to mission control and then do a "quicklook" (for that read "slow look") on the windows in a stack in mission control by moving the mouse over the window and pressing the space bar, then pressing it again to get it to go away, and then again to see the next window, and so on and so on, until you *eventually* get the

window you are looking for. This is in *no way* an improvement.


Now, I for one would be perfectly happy witht having an "application windows" feature for all the windows in a stack just by howering over the stack. When you do an "all windows" you know what application you are looking for, so having to move to the mouse to the stack for correct application and then to see only those windows would actually be an "all windows" improvement since the windows would be bigger, without the windows from appliocations you are not interested in and the amount of mouse movement would be no greater. It is all the uneccessary clicking and keyboard interaction that is annoying me. As it is, hovering the

mouse shows a blue line around the window, so why not just have it do a quick look instead of needing the

actual space bar press?

Oct 15, 2011 6:28 AM in response to airbnboy

Oh, and by the way, before any one posts, yes I know I can *almost* get the "applications windows" experience

on a stack with a two finger swipe, but the windows don't open up enough to see what is going on, and doing a two finger swipe is as much work as a mouse click if you are just moving the mouse around. Just open them up them up completely when the mouse is over them is what you want.

Oct 30, 2011 10:11 PM in response to airbnboy

I completely agree with airbnboy. I used to be able to quick organised different windows within the same app to different spaces (now "desktops" for no apparent reason). This worked very smoothly in expose/spaces. I'd use one gesture to get to spaces, then another for expose, and I'd have all my windows in all spaces visible.


Now, I can't even see all of my windows in specific to one desktop! The best I can do is double scroll to see *some parts* of the windows on a desktop. So now, selecting a window for a specifc app is huge pain.


Worse than this, on moving windows from a desktop to another in, Mission Control will change the ordering of the stacks (per app, not the windows in the stacks). Umm, what is the possible benefit there?


So, now there is no use of spatial memory - e.g. Window X for App Y was in the top left of all my windows in the top left space, and I want to move it now. It's no longer possible to see all app windows in a specific "desktop", and much more effort is required to move windows around.


Great, well done Apple. Can we please, please have Expose and Spaces back as an option? Or at the very least, some way to view all windows for a specifc app on a specific desktop - and by "view", I mean see the whole window, not just a tiny indicator of the window, or a slightly expanded stack that may not give enough context.


The only reason I "upgraded" to Lion was to get XCode 4.2.

Oct 31, 2011 2:16 AM in response to airbnboy

My opinion has changed as I've used Mission control more, and since the updates that Apple have made after I first joined this discussion. I have a suspicion that this might be becuase I'm using a Magic Track pad on my iMac and the normal pad on my MacBook Pro; the various four finger gestures make navigating Mission Control easy. For example, four fingers down shows me all the windows in the current app - which is what I think Croysk is struggling with.


Are other people using Mice?

1 OSX Lion Mission Control vs Snow Leopard Expose can't we combine the two (by leaving older Expose options inside) and get Apple back to leaping forward again?

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple ID.