I'm adding myself to this list too.
I purchased the iMac just recently from a friend and found that the left half of the screen was darker than the right. I took it to the Garden State Plaza store for repair, I was happy to pay a fair price to get it to work properly since this was a pre-owned machine that I purchased from a friend for a good price.
When I got to the store I told the tech right away that this 27" iMac was part of the class of devices covered under the GPU repalcement program and that the most likely cause of the problem was the GPU and the logic board. I was told they would look at it and make the necessary repairs. After 4 days the store called and I went back in to pick it up. They had replaced the LCD. When I arrived at the store and the tech powered up the iMac in front of me I could see that the screen was now bright across the full width of the screen but now had a bright 1 inch stripe of washed out color all the way around the perimeter of the screen. I was a little confused because they said it was done, but obviously it was not. I assume the tech didn't bother to actually look at the screen before he/she marked it off as complete.
My wife and I had to wait 35 minutes for a 2nd tech to be brought to us to look at the screen, who looked at it and who then called on his manager to look at it as well. We had to wait another 15 minutes for the tech manager to look and he saw what everyone else did, a big bright stripe that shouldn't be there. We asked them what they had done and they claimed that they tested the Backlight and found it to be in order, so they then replaced the LCD. They indicated that they would have to keep the iMac for several more days until parts came in.
4 days later the store calls me back again telling me the iMac is ready, come pick it up. I arrive at the store and as soon as they power the iMac the light stripe is still there. The tech failed again to check on the screen before marking it as complete. I was furious at this point. I had wasted two 1.5 hour drives to get to the store only to discover that they had not done their job. I had paid the store $580 for a repair that they hadn't done properly.
Now the crazy part, the tech du jour tells me that they are going to replace the logic board and the GPU. If you recall, the first thing I told the first tech who received my iMac 2 weeks prior was that the logic board and GPU were most likely the issue. They asked me to leave the iMac again to that they can replace the GPU and logic board, and that it would be ready sometime soon. I actually had to ask the tech to put notes in their system to request they QA the monitor before calling me so that I don't waste another trip. I would have to drop another $200 to fix do this repair which would bring my bill up to $780. Again, going back to the beginning, I am happy to pay for the repair, I purchased this computer knowing it needed to be repaired, so it has not been a question of money. It has not become a question of time, I am losing far too much of it because of Genius Bar incompetence.
I have decided that at this point I am going to ask to speak with the store manager to tell him how dissastisfied I am with their Genius Bar staff and the overall experience I've had with this repair. It's not the cost or the work required, it's the fact that twice the store told me they had repaired something and failed to properly test and verify their work before calling me and having me drive 1.5 hours roundtrip just to leave the store empty handed.