Nikon Coolscan V ED and iMac Core Duo

Anybody using their Coolscan V ED, or another film or flatbed scanner, with the new iMac Core Duo? I plan purchasing the CS V ED in the very near future, but unsure whether it will work well with the new iMac.

15" PB G4, 20" iMac Core Duo, and a few iPods, Mac OS X (10.4.4)

Posted on Jan 23, 2006 7:26 PM

Reply
32 replies

Apr 10, 2006 2:18 PM in response to philip ireland

I have a IV ED with Nikon Scan 3.1.4 and an Intel
iMac and it works perfectly


That's very good to hear.

What about NikonScan 4.0 though? Could you try it out and let us know?

Because here's the official word from Nikon...

Currently Nikon products and software applications are not supported on Macintosh computers powered by the Intel Core Duo processor. Compatibility and support for Nikon products and software with Macintosh computers powered by the Intel Core Duo processor is currently under review by the Nikon Quality department. At this time we do not have any time-tables regarding when we will or if we will issue drivers and software support for this new system. Rest assured that Nikon will make every effort to support all the latest technologies developed by Apple and Microsoft. Keep checking our Knowledge Database system for updates regarding this issue over the upcoming months.

http://support.nikontech.com/cgi-bin/nikonusa.cfg/php/enduser/stdadp.php?p_faqid=13865&pcreated=1139239488

Anyone out there using a Nikon CoolScan LS-5000 & NikonScan 4.0 with an Intel based Mac?

Apr 10, 2006 2:35 PM in response to sparky67

Here is my little exchange with Nikon today...

After they referred me to the FAQ that I already read.

ME: "Thank-you for your reply but I still think you've failed to answer my question. The article you refer me to with your link is main reason I contacted you. I'd like you to escalate this issue to somebody that can answer my questions in more detail...

Which BRAND-NEW Macintosh computers are supported with the Nikon LS5000 scanners?

Does Nikon intend to support Mac? If so, then when, since all new Macintosh computers now have Intel processors?

It's already been four months of new Intel Macs, I'd expect Nikon to have at least some small idea of how much longer would before the Mac platform is again supported?

What's even more disturbing is that I only stumbled upon this issue by browsing this support forum. I was on the verge of purchasing at least four and possibly up to eight scanners and corresponding computers. That would have been a financial disaster for my company considering the lack of support and the seeming lack of concern by Nikon regarding the new Mac computers.

NOWHERE in your sales literature or the Nikon Coolscan website does it say that Macs with Intel processors are not supported. The sales literature only states that Macs require at least a G3 processor or better. Most people would read that and assume that a brand new Mac with the latest processor would be better than a G3.

Shame on Nikon for hiding this issue under the rug and not providing a prompt solution for their very loyal customers."


NIKON: "Hello,
These days new operating system version pop up every other week.
We strive to keep our products up to date with the latest operating systems out there, and work closely with Microsoft and Apple to see that this support comes as quickly as possible.
Apple is still offering systems with the PowerPC processors, like the iBook G4, Power Book G4, and the Power Mac G5.
As of today, we do not support the new Mac systems with the Intel chipset, but this is currently being looked into. We have no other information to offer at this time.
Thank you,
Dave"



ME: "These days new operating system version pop up every other week." LOL- You must be thinking of Windows where there are nearly a dozen versions not counting the new Vista.

But I understand. Nikon is working on it and you have no further information. That's fine.

However, your sales literature is seriously flawed. It says that the scanner will be compatible with a G3 or better processor. If your equipment doesn't work with the newer Intel processor, then it's NOT compatible with a G3 or better; it's ONLY compatible with a G3, G4, & G5.

My complaint is that you should either make a note in your literature at least for your vendors or issue an estimated date of when you're going to fix the problem.

As I explained, this is a PRE-SALES question and your attitude towards me is troubling. I was looking to purchase between four and eight of these scanners and because of inaccurate information in YOUR brochures, I almost purchased thousands of dollars of useless computer systems.

Maybe you should forward my question up the chain of command at Nikon... to somebody that cares more about what POTENTIAL customers think.

Meanwhile, I will post this issue at dozens of Mac user forums so that others don't make a big mistake by thinking a new Nikon scanner will work on their new Mac computer system.


NIKON: "Hello,
We certainly do care about potential customers, which is why we will not offer any software that is not ready to be released. Software development takes a very long time to finalize, and involves a huge amount of testing before it is published publicly. Our timetable for software release for this new technology is unclear at this point, and we apologize for that.
As for the product literature, it will be updated to include this new item in time, and our vendors are supplied with up to date support information on a regular basis. At the time of publication, all information on the brochures was correct and up to date.
Thank you for pointing that out, however, and I will be happy to pass your comments onto our QA team for review.
Regards,
Dave"





I think everyone with a Nikon Scanner who is considering the purchase of an Intel Mac or vice-versa should send Nikon a flood of complaints regarding the issue. How long can this really take them? The new Macs have been out for quite a while now.
In my experience, Nikon has excellent equipment but once they identify an issue, they do nothing to resolve it. It gets swept under until the next scanner is released.
Example: The older LS-4000 scanner had firewire communication "issues". Issues that were never fully resolved but the LS-5000 scanner is now USB-2.0


(2) B & W G3 500 & AGP Gigabit G4 450 Mac OS X (10.4.6)

May 12, 2006 3:43 PM in response to sparky67

I can 100% verify the following-

- NikonScan version 4.02
- Mac OS X.4.5
- Mac Mini 1.66 Ghz Intel Core Duo
- Nikon LS-4000ED scanner (Firewire 400)

The above setup does seem to work normally without any problems.

However, I would need to run LS-5000ED scanners which are USB 2.0.

I can only assume that a USB model like the LS-5000ED should work similarly.

Anyone see a problem with that logic?

May 18, 2006 11:13 AM in response to sparky67

Yes, a Nikon LS-5000ED scanner with the USB 2.0 interface works with an Intel Duo Core 1.66 Ghz Mac Mini - 512 MB RAM.

Using the latest NikonScan 4.02 software and OS X.4.6 with all the updates.

No problems yet.

Hopefully the Universal Binary version of NikonScan will be available soon as I think it could run faster. Especially after Apple stops making the PPC models later this year.

Jul 2, 2006 5:39 PM in response to sparky67

Hello,

I have been trying to use Nikon Scan V4 and 4+ with a Nikon 4000ED on my Macbook Pro 17", using 10.4.6

It has been very frustrating.
The main issue is the eject command of all things. It hangs the Nikon Scan software and the scanner keeps trying to eject endlessly.
The only work around I have found is to keep restarting all the parts till it lets go.

When you can get a scan done, they seem to work just fine. Overall workflow-wise though with the eject problem, this is a disaster.

If you come across a solution, I'd appreiate knowing your experience.

Thanks!

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

Nikon Coolscan V ED and iMac Core Duo

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.