miniStack + Powerbook + Firewire

Here's my situtation:

I have been running low on disk space on my Powerbook for some time, and I finally bought an external hard drive. I went with the Newertechnologies miniStack and installed a Hitachi 7200 rpm 250 GB hard drive.

I set it up as a firewire drive, and thats when it happened. I started transferring large media files off of my Powerbook and onto the miniStack and this is what happened:

A progress bar would pop up as usual, and show the progress of the data. The drive would click, start to make a noise like it was starting to spin real fast and the data would move quicly in the progress bar. Then the drive would stop transferring data, make a clicking noise and start up again. This happens in a semi-regular interval until the file is done transferring.

When I configure the miniStack to USB, the data transfers at the slow USB pace that I have come to know and expect.

I don't know much about hard drives and firewire, but it seems to me as if the drive is to fast for the Firewire. What I mean by this is, it seems that the hard drive would send out data through the firewire at a fast pace, and then would stop so that the firewire could catch up, maybe creating some type of bottleneck of data. Like I said, I am not even sure if this is possible, but that's what is it seems like to me.

Also, I have heard that the firewire components that Apple installs in it's line of iBooks and Powerbooks are actually slower than those in desktops. I wonder if this could be manifesting itself now.

So, all ranting aside, I was curious if anyone had experienced anything similar to what I am experiencing right now, or can confirm or deny my theory about the firewire bottleneck, or the rumor about the Powerbook firewire being slower than those on the desktops.

I will try to connect my miniStack to a PowerMac at school and see if I get the same results.

Thanks

Powerbook G4 1.33, Mac OS X (10.3.9), 5G iPod, Airport Express, Airport Snow

Posted on Jan 26, 2006 2:19 PM

Reply
2 replies

Feb 22, 2006 7:07 PM in response to Akuma

I called OWC at 18002754576 in regard to the same issue, and the technician blamed the issue on a bug in OSX.
He asked to verify that "Ignore privileges" is checked when you GET INFO on the drive. It should help.

Another weird phenomenon I noticed is that the the problem never occurs when you copy large files from the ministack to another drive.
And did I mention that I have better chances of success when I copy files from the PB superdrive than from my external SONY FW dvd drive?

On a positive note, I find the Ministack works very well for me as a startup disk. It appears that my PB runs faster (of course, it takes longer to start the computer, however, a whole 15-30 secs just for the screen to go on after you hear the chime).

Mysteries of FW and OSX.
Regards




PB 12" Mac OS X (10.4.2) 512, DVD

Feb 22, 2006 7:38 PM in response to Alfonso

Alfonso,

Thanks for the reply. I connected my miniStack to a PowerMac G5 running 10.4 and it worked flawlessly. I got firewire speeds of about 40 MB/ps, which is what I've come to know and love about firewire.

So, I don't know if it is the OS, or the Powerbook, but that wouldn't make sense since you seem to be running Tiger and its not working for you.

Also, I noticed that the firewire works better with a certain port on the miniStack, which seems odd. I think I am going to return it or get a replacement.

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

miniStack + Powerbook + Firewire

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.