iTunes Play Count isn't accurate

I love iTunes...but the iTunes Play Count just isn't accurate. It's not accurate because people often flick to the next song when the current song is 95% complete. That's because the last few seconds of a song may contain guitars fading out, white noise or even just silence and if you've an iPod in your hand or iTunes at your fingertips, people often just select the next song.

iTunes Play Count only counts a song as being played if it plays every single second of a song. But if you listen to 5 minutes and 56 seconds of a 6 minute song, surely you've still heard the song, right? Therefore, I think iTunes should count a song as being played if you've played, say 90% of the song. That seems like the best compromise.

Yes, I've emailed the suggestion in a couple of times over the years but no-one is listening. Does anyone else think this is something that should be changed? Looking forward to hearing your comments - or better still, tell Apple!

(Yes, I know the Play Count is useless to a lot of people but I like it. But I don't like the fact that some of my very favourite songs, the songs I've played maybe hundreds of times, only show up as being played a handful of times - that's because they're sometimes the last track on an album and may have minutes of feedback or noise etc as the album winds down. But I've heard the song, so iTunes should count it!)

Gavin

Powerbook G4, Mac OS X (10.4.4)

Posted on Jan 28, 2006 4:37 AM

Reply
2 replies

Jan 28, 2006 7:14 AM in response to Gavin Smith

iTunes Play Count only counts a song as being played if it plays every single second of a song.

iTunes only needs to play the last second or two of a track to have the play count incremented, so you could move the slider all the way over until only a could seconds are left to have iTunes count it as a play. If there are tracks you constantly stop early, you can set up a custom stop time in the tracks Get Info box. iTunes will increment the play count when the custom stop is reached. The iTunes play counter is a simple counter that adds a count each time the end-of-file is reached. iTunes has no mental telepathy to increment the counter based on what a user thinks is the end of the tune. There are scripts on Doug's AppleScripts for iTunes to adjust the playcounts of one or more tracks.

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

iTunes Play Count isn't accurate

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.