AT&T 64GB White: San Antonio, TX (With full HSPA+ coverage and 1 of the 3 AT&T test markets for LTE ... but obviously I can't take advantage of the LTE with the 4S)
It's not just related to ios 5. I am a dev. and have been running the Beta, now GM for months. On my older iPhone 4, I saw a definite drop in Battery Life on early Beta's; however, this was fixed over time and each new Beta provided me with better battery life. Before the GM was released, I saw virtually no difference between my iPhone 4 battery performance from iOS 4.3.3 and 5.0 Beta 7 (plus a few days on the GM; prior to moving over to the 4S) The slight drop in battery life can easily be attributed to the extra background tasks being implemented in the OS. Upon upgrading (?) to the 4S last Friday, I immediately noticed a DRAMATIC difference in battery life. I've seen a number of posts in this forum, along with posts in Apple-Centric Blogs which seem to indicate that this is not a universal problem and that many (if not most) of the new 4S owners not experiencing this problem. Regardless; with over 4 million phones sold in the opening weekend, it only takes a very small percentage of owners to provide a very large base of people having problems.
Regarding individuals who post that you should turn off 50% - 80% of the phones functions to "make it work"; that's just absurd. Thease are core functions / features of the phone and you should not have to turn any of them off in order to make the phone usable.
I drained my battery down to 3% last night (early) and let it charge fully to 100%. after 2 1/2 hours of being unplugged, I have made 2 phone calls (under 60 seconds each) and performed 3 brief SIRI inquiries. My battery level is now down to 83%.
on my iPhone 4 (under the various iOS 5 beta's) I would regularly put heavy usage on the device throughout the day. I'd listen to a combination of streaming music (MOG, iHeart Radio, TWIT, TII ...) and podcasts / Audiobooks / music which resided on my phone. I easily spent about an hour a day talking on the phone and used a vast array of apps; which I did not "Kill" after exiting. The only time I ever connected the dock connector was to upload test application code to the phone, or to charge overnight. I seldom had to worry about a low battery during the day; only needing to give a booster charge in the early evening, if I knew I would need it for a few more hours.
This is obviously not the case with my 4S. While Apple may eventually isolate the cause, I can't afford to wait and have made a Genius Bar appointment to see about getting a phone swap.
In the mean time, I have a suggestion for everyone on this forum. It won't fix anything, but it might help discern if there is anything in common with the phones that are experiencing this problem. Just as I have done at the top of this post. If everyone posting new messages will start with the model specifications (amount of RAM & black vs. white) along with your carrier and general location, it might (absolutely no guarantees) point out a commonality among those experiencing this problem. On the other hand, if there are no common threads (outside of the fact that they are all iPhone 4S devices) this is still useful information to collect and pass on to Apple for their own internal search for a cuase / fix. Just a suggestion.