Apple Event: May 7th at 7 am PT

Looks like no one’s replied in a while. To start the conversation again, simply ask a new question.

Why is Motion3 degrading my non-compressed exported clips?

Going nuts here -- coming into the home stretch of a very long old movie/vidoe restoration project in Motion 3, and even though I've been exporting my cleanup work into solid clips with "none" as my compressor, the image qulity is degrading -- type and video that was clean and sharp is blurred! I thought I had the mystery solved when i stopped working in 16 bit color space for my 8 bit capture (thought the larger color space would give me better levels tweaking, but it didn't -- made images look blurred), but now that i'm down to the wire and wanting to export ( "none" compression again) a last time to work with audio and chapter markers, all of a sudden (so it seems) my images are blurring! this is making me crazy.


I thought working with no compression -- not even "animation" -- had solved my problem with successive image degradation that lots of image stabilization, replacement and cleanup was bringing when using animation, apple intermediate codec, even prores compressors; "none" for compression literally cleared the problem up. Now seems it's all going down the crapper as i come to an end of my work. Even after constant trashing of Motion's prefs for all I've been pushing it to do this.


Anybody else have this problem ever, or am i or my project (or both) hopelessly snakebit? Also, have no choice but to use Motion 3, of FCS2, cuz I'm working on a Dual 2 G5 PPC -- no moneys to upgrade.


thanks

Mac OS X (10.5.8), Dual2 PowerMac G5, 4 GB RAM

Posted on Nov 3, 2011 9:45 AM

Reply
1 reply

Nov 3, 2011 11:33 PM in response to appleganger

Never mind.


Learning all sorts of valuable lessons the REALLY hard way.


Video not looking so bad anymore -- going darker for NTSC made images look not quite as sharp, but up large, the difference in clarity between their darker and lighter states is negligible -- also, seems Motion doesn't display the files (esp. after exporting with effects) quite as sharply as QuickTime does by itself.


Hmmmm.


NEVER create type files in any HD format and then expect them to translate well to SD, esp 640 x 480. They might look fairly ok starting out (kinda "filmic", actually), but don't go and further reduce their size AT ALL. Big-time fuzz-blur city, bigger-time project delays while frantically sleuthing the causes and wondering why-the-heck it's happenin' to you, and then it's off with the men in white coats to happy la-la land at the State's expense.


Well maybe not quite that bad, but i'm SO glad I'm my own client on this project......



Comments, corrections are welcome -- plz go easy, tho.

Why is Motion3 degrading my non-compressed exported clips?

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple ID.