MBP late 2011 sd card write extremely slow

I have a Macbook Pro late 2011 all Lion updates applied and want to use the integrated SD Card Reader (which, according to System Profiler is connected directly to the PCIe Bus).


My SD card is a brand new Sandisk Extreme Pro, which is rated for 95MB/sec and 90MB/sec write speed. Reading from the card is quite fast, I get over 88MB/sec. Writing, however, is abysmally slow. I could not get more than 12,6MB/sec write speed (tested via transferring a 4GB ISO Image from/to the internal SSD). The same card on an old USB 2.0 reader connected to an ancient PC gives around 20MB/sec. I did not test it on another device with a fast SD reader yet.


A google search turned up a review on amazon where e

Macbook Pro, Mac OS X (10.7.2)

Posted on May 26, 2012 11:41 AM

Reply
9 replies

May 28, 2012 4:14 AM in response to schmadde

Nobody?


I just tested the same card in an USB 3.0 reader connected to a PC. I get approximately the same read performance (89 MB/sec) but more than 6x the write performance (77MB/sec). I also tried "Black Magic Disk Speed test" on the Macbook Pro. It gives even lower numbers.


Something really is wrong with the internal SD Card reader. Does nobody else have that problem?

May 29, 2012 3:07 AM in response to Shootist007

Well using an SD Card in an SD card slot does not sound so awfully strange to me. I really just wanted to test the cards performance and capacity because Sandisks are faked so often.


I have an idea, however. The Card is slower if written to in small block sizes - it needs a quite large block size to reach its performance. I will have a look into it.

May 29, 2012 4:03 AM in response to schmadde

The SD slot on a late model like yours can read/write at 2.5GT/sec (gigatransfers). Don't ask me what that is in Mbps, but much faster than the 480Mbps (60 MB/s) of the older macbook pros. The limit is the card and the file system. Probably formatted at MSDOS-FAT32 by most cameras, windoze will probably like it better.


The card is classed and optimized for camera use - several smallish files around 10MB at a time. testing to near destruction with massive blocks of data will tell you nothing and won't do the card any good. If your camera will take multiple shots of RAW and save them in a couple of seconds in the camera then that's what is important.


Put the SDHC card in, go to About this Mac, system report, then Card Reader and see what the Mac thinks you have. My class 10 shows up as class 4 so somebody is wrong, probably the factory that put the labels on my bargain class 10 card!

Jul 23, 2012 7:14 AM in response to schmadde

I just bought SANDISK EXTREME PRO 16GB. I want to use it as backup of my system (right now I backup my system to 16GB USB but i was hoping to get much faster performance). It reads at 45MB but writes at 9MB which is really dissapointing. When I connect card via USB reader it writes at 15MB. My macbook pro 2011 recognizes the card as CLASS 10.

I wonder if it's hardware thing or there will be OSX update? I have OSX 10.6.8. What do you guys think? I was hoping the new superfast cards could be bridge between regural HD and SSD. You can buy 128GB SD card pretty cheap comparing to SSD not to mention it could be great as portable disk.

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

MBP late 2011 sd card write extremely slow

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.