Hi to all guys,
This is my first post in this matter, but I'm reading almost daily the updates of this problem with battery on Macbook Pro's.
I do also suffer from the same problem, I got a Early 2011 Macbook Pro 15'' (750GB HDD model/AMD HD6750 GPU) and I have it since about 19 months. It came with Lion installed and so far the Lion experience was really good with no issues worthy to talk about.
When Mountain Lion came out I rush into buy it and install it to use all those wonderful IOS-port features, specially cause I use other Apple products like iPad, iPhone, Apple TV, etc...
About 2 or 3 months ago I notice the message that my battery needs to be replaced, I'm a system dev engineer and I now how I use my computers. I was really worried cause the way I use was not near the same heavy-work I do on some other Windows laptops I'll have in the past.
I started my research and end up like most of you guys in this post of the forum, wondering if someone would have the same "luck" i have, but manage to get some word-around, cause in my opinion... everything start-up with the Mountain Lion upgrade.
I was really interested in Franc_iPhone's experience and hoped it would help me out, cause my battery was losing the amount of charge FAST... I use to have 7 hours with Lion, and with this problem I now have a battery that only charges 962 mAH, which is less than an iPhone battery (as a note I use the Sistem Information App and go the Power... there is a lot of information there that CoconutBattery app use to display). Varely that amount could only for 25 minutes. It began losing mAH from the original amount which is 6900 mAH almost daily and sometimes abructly (once I just turn it off and was in about 4200 mAH and when I turn it on was only 2900 mAH).
TODAY, yes (just before the release of the 10.8.3 patch) I was really **** off and read that someone else does a clean install of ML and got lucky. I made the same procedure, erase all the partitions (except the recovery) in the HDD (even bootcamp) and install from Internet again the ML 10.8.2 OS. The result was the same, it change only a few mAH (no more than 10). After I finish and went to see any updates I was amazed about the fact the 10.8.3 patch was out today (kinda crazy for me at that moment, after i wipe out everything). I install the patch and the result... WAS THE SAME, my battery is only at 962 mAH. I make some test (use it with the battery, use it with the power-cord, turn it off, reboot, etc... etc...), the end result is the same and sadly it seems that my problem is hardware related and (to me at least) the ML could have trigger some malicius behavior on my Macbook that end up with this issue.
I live in Latin America and here a Macbook cost almost the double than a similar computer on Windows OS. I have a Asus 3D Laptop that after 2.5 years it still give you the same amount of battery life, even though was only 2.5 hours... and I use it for work and also for playing games (something I avoid in the Macbook, so Mac was in an easy ride). IMO, such price for this type of products should give you a much much much better experience that other products less costly.
As Metallica song says... "its sad, but true". At least for me I think my ride on Apple laptop is over, I can't handle myself to think it would be wise to invest more money on a really pricy piece of equipment and get issues I don't have on less-costly equipment, that in many cases does get the job done.
Hope anyone else could get better result than me... sure there is a lot people out there with issues, this moment the thread got 325699 views, which surely Apple SHOULD put attention to it if it cares of its customers.
Ciao and good luck,