I bought an iPhone that was reported stolen by the seller

I bought an iPhone 4 with the screen cracked. I replaced the screen and was using it as a personal iPhone. Today it got blocked. So I called AT&T and they told me the phone was reported stolen.

So, here is what I assume happened. The seller broke the phone, so in order to get a replacement phone he reported it stolen. He got the replacement, and sold me the broken one.

Now, AT&T, even tho Im telling them this guy lied to them to get a new phone, they refuse to contact him or help me in any way.

So I went back to my calls, and I have the calls of Saturday 11 from 6pm and I bought the phone Saturday midday. Basically I cant have his number now. There were no text messages involved either.


So, me question is; is there any way to retrieve the calls from Saturday 11 before 6pm?

Posted on Aug 17, 2012 5:52 PM

Reply
49 replies

Aug 17, 2012 8:11 PM in response to steve359

Ajax, trust me next time I buy something I will cover my back. Now, I gotta figure this out. I will tell the police the truth. There was a lady sharing the Starbucks table where we made the deal. I have no clue who she is but if I see here again Ill recognize her. The other witness is his gf or wife who the phone he said belonged to.

Maybe he found the phone at publix and came up with that story he gave me. I dont even wanna keep thinking of possible truths. Im gonna seek legal help, Im fearless, I know I didnt do anything wrong, and if I would've been the thieft I wouldnt go to the police to protest I got screwed, right?

Hopefully his number will show up in craigslist when he needs to sell something. Im dying to get to meet him again.

Aug 17, 2012 8:12 PM in response to AjaxOfSalamis

I was trying to drill into the OP how much your life can be messed up if ATT decides to *never* run the pretty little wires into your house so that you can have high-speed internet. Or that the police may track down the hone nmubers called to get back to the OP. The remarks I have seen indicate that the OP feels he/she can control the police/districtattorney/phonecompany.


Seems that is more important right now.

Aug 17, 2012 8:17 PM in response to iLS6

Don't confront the guy. You have zero proof that you even gave him any money, so if talk to him he can go to the police and claim you stole the phone from him and are now harassing him, and the only record anybody has of anything is that you made some phone calls from his iPhone.


File a report with your local police, consult with a lawyer if you like, and then just write it off as an expensive lesson learned.

Aug 17, 2012 8:20 PM in response to AjaxOfSalamis

AjaxOfSalamis wrote:


Don't confront the guy.


File a report with your local police, consult with a lawyer if you like, and then just write it off as an expensive lesson learned.


Agreed. The OP can get assault charges if he/she gets "stupid" while contronting. No offense intended ... I too would call the police to avoid risking legal problems because of losing control and getting "stupid".

Aug 17, 2012 8:56 PM in response to iLS6

So, here is what I assume happened. The seller broke the phone, so in order to get a replacement phone he reported it stolen

Why didn't he just report it broken and get a new one? If he had it insured for loss, he also had it insured for damage.


The person I bought if from did not stole it. He broke it, then reported stolen so insurance will give him a new one.

How do you know any of this?

Aug 17, 2012 10:45 PM in response to Chris CA

Chris CA


I do not know that. I was trying to give myself an answer of what was going on. But then I remember him telling me he will be wearing his green Publix shirt when I was waiting for him at Starbucks. Then I came up with a new theory in my head, that maybe he found the phone while working and sold it giving me the story of it being his gf's iphone that felt and broke.

Then, once I got 2 different theories in my head I realized I will never really know what really happened.

If ppl dnt want to believe me, I dont really care. I've had enough today.


Let me add a little detail as of why I say I've had enough today.


I sold my older 3G iphone today. While my phone was working.

The buyer showed up, called me saying he was outside. I showed him my old 3G iphone. I took my sim card out of my iphone 4 for him to test out the 3G using a sim adapter. Everything was perfect. He paid me, took the phone and left.


I put my sim back in my phone, try to make a call.. get a machine telling me my device has been blocked for service. I went crazy, called customer service from my shop's phone, it was a mission to get to talk to somebody after calls kept dropping. Then they told me the phone was not gonna work again.


I restored the phone hoping that would help me get it back and running. And while Im doing it, this buyer of my 3G shows up all ****** off saying that I sold him a stolen iPhone and that he worked for the police and bla bla bla (DUDE, DO YOU REALLY THINK IM GONNA MEET YOU AT MY OWN SHOP TO ROB YOU?????)

At that time I thought it was a problem with the sim, that it was just gonna be ok. Gave him his money back, he apologized for his attitude and said to me - I thought you robbed me cause when they told me the phone was stolen I tried to call you and your phone was disconnected.

I didnt have an answer, I just showed him my own phone, the one he called on an hour ago now gives the same machine msg.


Now my iPhone 4 is a hot phone, stolen, in my hands with all my personal info in it. My sim card doesnt work anymore. Now my very own 3G comes up as stolen so I dont have ANY phone right now. And we are supposed to live in a first world country. Bro, really? The great USA ??


So yeah, through all that I went today. While being an honest person doing honest businesses, at least on my end. Then I get here trying to get some advise on how to handle this, thinking that maybe somebody could help me reason cause Im all ****** off, confused, now even worried and I get some support, then ppl turned around and now I am the bad guy.


Thats more than enough. This horrible experience will pass, I will learn from it, and mature.


As far as this guy who screwed me, God is watching, whether you wanna believe it or not makes no difference, He is taking his notes.

Aug 17, 2012 10:58 PM in response to iLS6

So your personal number is now associated with a stolen phone, and your personal phone is now bricked. You cannot transfer your unmber to a new carrier, because ATT must release it and the new carrier must contact ATT to do this.


And ATT has evidence (two phones using the same stolen number) to use against you.


Get a lawyer. You are deep in the brown stinky stuff.

Aug 18, 2012 3:46 AM in response to iLS6

I have a major correction to make!!! It wasn't a Publix I was in, it was a Winn-Dixie. Whew, glad I caught that. Details matter, ya know. 😉


iLS6, "OP" is shorthand for Original Poster. That's you.


In all seriousness, I would go to an ATT store, explain the situation to them and see what steps, if any, can be taken. WickedOne60 (post on the second page) makes some good points, and it may turn out there is nothing you can do that could easily resolve the situation. You've invested a lot so far in terms of time and money. It's your call if you want to continue, but if it were me, I'd cut my losses: throw the repaired phone out, and get a new phone, new provider contract, and a new phone number.


Good luck with whatever path you take.

Jan 5, 2013 10:47 AM in response to Lawrence Finch

yea that like 450 dollars more than what I am buying. I spoke with an Apple representative and they told me my new carrier has to make the transfer, that I need to ask for that along with bringing my number.

Details, Im buying a 64gb 4S for 400 from its original owner. Apple doesnt even sell those anymore unless I get a 2 years contract. And even if there were, it will cost twice as much.

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

I bought an iPhone that was reported stolen by the seller

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.