When you were with Rogers, your modem/router acted as two separate devices. The modem portion provided the Internet connection and the router portion of your modem/router provided the DHCP and NAT*** services for the network.
The AirPort Extreme was configured in the correct Bridge Mode settings because the modem/router was already providing DHCP and NAT services.
In Bridge Mode, DHCP and NAT are turned off and the AirPort Extreme acted as a pass through device for these services. This is because you never want two devices, both trying to act as routers on the same network.
When you do have two devices that can act as routers....as you did when you were still with Rogers.... one device (your modem/router) is configured to provide DHCP and NAT and the other device must be configured in Bridge Mode to prevent DHCP and NAT conflicts that would occur with two devices both competing with each other to do the same thing.
When you replaced the Rogers modem/router combination device, you had an Internet connection from the simple modem, but you lost the DHCP and NAT services that the modem/router formerly provided. Now, the AirPort Extreme is acting as your main router....not a bridge as it was before....and it is the AirPort Exteme that is now providing DHCP and NAT services for your network.
***
DHCP is the service that supplies IP addresses to each device on the network
NAT is the service that allows a single Internet connection to share its services with all devices on the network